Please see embedded remarks below.
Dick
-----Original Message-----
From: Tony Duell <ard(a)p850ug1.demon.co.uk>
To: Discussion re-collecting of classic computers
<classiccmp(a)u.washington.edu>
Date: Tuesday, November 30, 1999 2:16 PM
Subject: Re: Needed: 1 IBM 8" alignment disk.
>> It's search algorithm is really funny too:
>>
>> Read Sector <-------------
>> If requested Sector <> address then |
>> If CRC not okay then ---------------------|
>>
It's not as odd as you may think. The CRC is for the ID field, so it's got
to keep trying to read the ID before it can determine whether it should read
the following data field. The controller doesn't have a fixed number of
retries, since the infinite loop, in the designers' opinion, allowed you to
poke around with your instruments looking for the problem, and is probably
as good as any other alternative. Remember, there's a CRC field after the
ID field, AND one after the data field. They both must pass check before
you get a valid sector.
This behavior is, however, quite consistent with a misadjusted PLL, or
whatever other mechanism they're using to extract the clock e.g. one-shots.
If someone has fiddled with the pots on the device, all bets are off as to
its ability to lock on the data. Since the data is synchronized differently
on every sector, it should be easy enough to determine whether lock occurs
just by triggering on the data stream while observing the PLL's oscillator.
Each sector should show a discrete and easily visible acquisition window.
Of course, that won't be the case with a naked but formatted diskette, since
its data and ID fields were written in one fell swoop, with no asynchronism
between sectors. However, if you format a new diskette on some OTHER and
WORKING compatible machine, writing a file to it will be a sector-by-sector
operation which will ostensibly have at least a short transient of phase
change reflecting the difference in phase between the relative position of
the diskette during formatting and during writing not to mention the minor
speed variations. In any case, you should, with your oscilloscope set up
properly, be able to watch a consisten acquisition of the data for each
sector. If you're not getting that, which is what I suspect, then your
error lies in that, the most basic task of a disk interface, without which
NOTHING else having to do with data transfer will work properly.
>> (you get the idea.. and infinite loop for most errors)
>
>Well, assuming it's getting into that loop, there's something to look at.
>Does it find a sector address? Does it match (and should it match --
>don't overlook a possible comparator problem). Does the CRC match? Should
>it? (again, don't overlook a possible problem with the logic here).
>
>Basically, you're in a loop (presumably stuck in some state(s) of a state
>machine). You should be thinking about the following :
>
>What signals can get it out of those states?
>Are they ever asserted?
>
>What events would cause them to be asserted?
>Do those events ever occur?
>What about the logic that detects said events and turns them into signals?
>
>-tony
>
>IMHO, it makes little sense to retain media for washing-machine-sized
>disk drives if you don't retain the drives and maintain them in order to
>retain the value of the media. Hindsight is always 20/20, but wouldn't
>it make sense to archive data/software on an archival medium, likely, we
>hope, to remain useable over time, rather than to store it on what's
>intended for on-line storage, and is likely to become obsolete within a
>couple of years of when it was developed?
Unless there is no equivalent... I've got the exact problem with the
DECsystem-10 I got earlier this year... it came with two RP06 drives.
They are 3-phase drives. We don't yet have three phase power (or a
close approximation of it), so cannot run the drives. Without the
drives, we cannot even load the microcode for the machine, so it is
a very large paper-weight.
I've been looking of a non-three-phase replacement for the drives, but
we still would need three-phase to get the data off the disks I have.
We have, however, been getting all the data off the tapes so as not
to lose it.
It would be great if there was a massbus interface for a more recent
tape drive, and the same for a disk... it would be neat to be able to
have a DAT tape acting like a TU77 or something supported by the machine,
and a couple of SCSI or even IDE disks acting as RM03 or RP06 disks...
(anyone know of any? Anyone up for the challenge of designing one?)
Megan Gentry
Former RT-11 Developer
+--------------------------------+-------------------------------------+
| Megan Gentry, EMT/B, PP-ASEL | Internet (work): gentry!zk3.dec.com |
| Unix Support Engineering Group | (home): mbg!world.std.com |
| Compaq Computer Corporation | addresses need '@' in place of '!' |
| 110 Spitbrook Rd. ZK03-2/T43 | URL: http://world.std.com/~mbg/ |
| Nashua, NH 03062 | "pdp-11 programmer - some assembler |
| (603) 884 1055 | required." - mbg |
+--------------------------------+-------------------------------------+
Hi,
My name is John Meshna. The son of the late John J. Meshn Jr., the Surplus mogel.
I saw your post. I'm flattered that my father's memory lives on.
We closed the company around 1988. He died in 1982. Thanks for keeping his memory alive. John
> Home | Collection
>
>
>
> Software | Mailing Lists
>
>
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> [Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
>
> Re: Keyboards
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> * To: "Discussion re-collecting of classic computers" <classiccmp(a)u.washington.edu>
> * Subject: Re: Keyboards
> * From: Frank McConnell <fmc(a)reanimators.org>
> * Date: 06 Dec 1998 15:57:48 -0800
> * In-Reply-To: Stephen Dauphin's message of Sun, 6 Dec 1998 13:13:21 -0500 (EST)
> * References: <Pine.SUN.3.91-FP.981205235650.3615A-100000(a)osfn.org>
> * Reply-To: classiccmp(a)u.washington.edu
> * Sender: CLASSICCMP-owner(a)u.washington.edu
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Stephen Dauphin <ai705(a)osfn.org> writes:
> > On a related note, wasn't there a electronics surplus dealer of some
> > sort, perhaps based in Massachusetts, called "Meshna"? I'm wondering if
> > someone knows whether they are still in business. Any web search turns
> > up nothing.
>
> Here's info from one of their 1988 catalogs:
>
> John J. Meshna Jr., Inc.
> 19 Allerton Street
> Lynn, MA 01904
> Tel: (617) 595-2275
>
> -Frank McConnell
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> * References:
> o Re: Keyboards
> + From: Stephen Dauphin <ai705(a)osfn.org>
>
> * Prev by Date: Scanning Fiche
> * Next by Date: Re: x86 OS's
> * Prev by thread: Re: Keyboards
> * Next by thread: Re: Keyboards
> * Index(es):
> o Date
> o Thread
>
>
>
>
> Created by: Kevan Heydon on Monday, 07-Dec-1998 15:10:16 PST
Hello,
I am looking for an inexpensive framebuffer PMAGB-BA for a Personal
DECstation 5000/20.
Some advices about good sources of DEC surplus ?
Regards.
J.-P. Hofer
I'm working with a device which has
poor documentation but it says the
printer port is compatible with
a TI Silent 700. Do you know
what baud rate, character length
and parity the Silent 700 used ?
Tom Hickerson
tom(a)automatedtech.com
I just got two Heath H89's to replace the one my parents
took to the dump 10 years ago while I was away at
college. Both these machines seem to work fine -- they
will boot CP/M and I can run programs, etc. One of
them is in absolute mint condition -- a real beauty.
However, the vast majority of the disks I have (circa 1979)
are HDOS disks. I would like to be able to read these
disks and use the software (e.g., Walt Bilofsky's C
compiler), but I can't get any of my bootable HDOS
disks to boot. Would anyone be willing to make me a
bootable HDOS disk and mail it to me? If so, I would greatly
appreciate it. Let me know by email (dmb(a)ai.mit.edu) if you
would be willing to volunteer. :)
I'm also looking for any of Evryware's interactive fiction
(text adventure) games for the H89. They had a whole
series of these games (starting with "A Remarkable
Experience") and I would like to resurrect them by porting
them to a modern platform. (Yes, there are still people
who like text adventures. See the Usenet newsgroup
rec.arts.int-fiction for ample evidence of this!)
Back in 1994, I ported Crowther & Woods' Adventure
>from the original FORTRAN source (for PDP-10, I believe)
to an object oriented language called TADS that was developed
specifically for text adventures. This port was quite popular
with the rec.arts.int-fiction crowd, and was itself ported
to various other platforms, including Infocom's Z-Machine.
I actually contacted one of the Evryware founders --
they're still making games -- but they said they don't
have any copies of their H89 stuff anymore. So if
anyone has them and would be willing to furnish copies,
please let me know.
Finally, does anyone know if it's possible to read/write
H89 disks in a PC? I mean, I know that the disk format
is radically different, but are PC 5 1/4" drives even physically
capable of doing this? It would be very nice to have a
PC-based program that could create H89 disks from
disk images, and I'd love to write one, but frankly I'm a
software guy and have no clue about the hardware side
of floppy disk formats. If anyone has any sage advice,
I'd be much obliged.
Dave Baggett
dmb(a)ai.mit.edu
please see comments embedded below.
Dick
-----Original Message-----
From: Tony Duell <ard(a)p850ug1.demon.co.uk>
To: Discussion re-collecting of classic computers
<classiccmp(a)u.washington.edu>
Date: Monday, November 29, 1999 7:45 PM
Subject: Re: Needed: 1 IBM 8" alignment disk.
>> It isn't alignment as I can manually move the head very slightly back and
>> forth which does affect the data coming into the controller assembly but
>> does not help it find the actual sector... Therefore, hardware or an
anlog
>> adjustment
>>
>> I would like an alignment disk so I can use "their" tuning procedure to
make
>> this drive work quickly. It has a number of adjustments including :
Clock,
>> window, gap, etc...
>
These are not the usual things for which you'd want an alignment diskette.
>
>Most alignment disks do not include such tests (I am not saying that the
>IBM one you asked for doesn't). They're just raw drive alignement disks
>with catseye patterns for aligning the radial position, an index timing
>burst, etc.
>
>If you think there's an electronic problem then you don't really need an
>aligment disk. Start with the spindle speed, which I assume is right
>since it almost certainly uses a mains-powered induction motor. Still, it
>can't hurt to check that the index pulses occur at the right frequency.
>
>They'll be a master clock, probably also used for writing. Check this
>with a 'scope or frequency counter. If it's incorrect, find out why.
>
Generally, there isn't a master clock. Among the drives I've been working
on over the past months, none had onboard oscillators with the exception of
the microprocessor-controlled Mitsubishi. That's why there are one-shots
and the like. The writing is accomplished by using both outputs from a
flipflop which is toggled by every positive edge on the data stream which is
generated on the controller.
>
>Then take a formatted disk (format one yourself on your old CP/M machine
>if you have to ;-)). Read a sector continously. Display the off-disk data
>on one trace of a 'scope and the read clock on another. Does the read
>clock seem to be the right frequency? Is it locked wrt the data? If not,
>look at that read PLL (or whatever it uses).
>
Again, most drives don't have PLL's on them, but rather leave that to the
controller. It does appear that this drive and controller may not be
entirely separate. The adjustments for "window" and "gap" do sound like
they are just trims on a one-shot, though. I've seen adjustments like that
on old hard disks. As you may recall, almost all the early FDD's had FM
clock/data separation on board. This drive is probably no exception.
>
>Index timing is either very important (if, for example, the controller
>expects to see an address mark as the first thing after an index pulse)
>or not at all important at this stage.
>
>At this point you should at least be recovering data bits from the disk.
>So if it still can't find a sector, find out why not. Can it not find an
>address mark at all?. Or can it not find the header you're asking for.
>This is likely to be a digital problem. As I don't have schematics for
>this unit I can't comment any further.
>
>-tony
>
-----Original Message-----
From: Al Kossow <aek(a)spies.com>
To: Discussion re-collecting of classic computers
<classiccmp(a)u.washington.edu>
Date: Monday, November 29, 1999 10:05 PM
Subject: Re: Needed: 1 IBM 8" alignment disk.
>"I wonder if it really is working most of the way (i.e. it can read ID
>marks and even data) but there's a problem getting that read data to the
>CPU (shift registers, bus drivers, etc)."
>
>Are you trying this on your 8/I or 8/S ?
The PDP-8i.. (it works the same on both units).. This drive has a dual
buffer (50) and was made to be used on some of the slowest computers... The
manual claims from high speed to "DC"... I have it on the 8i as I don't like
to subject the 8/s to questionable hardware.
>
>>From memory, the Sykes interface is REALLY dumb. An 8/S might be too slow
>to handle the data rates..
>
It is... *really* dumb... Its got a 2 sector buffer option(claims it can do
2 things at the same time with the buffers) so I got a bigger really dumb
controller.
It's search algorithm is really funny too:
Read Sector <-------------
If requested Sector <> address then |
If CRC not okay then ---------------------|
(you get the idea.. and infinite loop for most errors)
john
PDP-8 and other rare mini computers
http://www.pdp8.com
-----Original Message-----
From: Tony Duell <ard(a)p850ug1.demon.co.uk>
To: Discussion re-collecting of classic computers
<classiccmp(a)u.washington.edu>
Date: Monday, November 29, 1999 9:40 PM
Subject: Re: Needed: 1 IBM 8" alignment disk.
>> It isn't alignment as I can manually move the head very slightly back and
>> forth which does affect the data coming into the controller assembly but
>> does not help it find the actual sector... Therefore, hardware or an
anlog
>> adjustment
>>
>> I would like an alignment disk so I can use "their" tuning procedure to
make
>> this drive work quickly. It has a number of adjustments including :
Clock,
>> window, gap, etc...
>
>
>Most alignment disks do not include such tests (I am not saying that the
>IBM one you asked for doesn't). They're just raw drive alignement disks
>with catseye patterns for aligning the radial position, an index timing
>burst, etc.
>
I hear you. This particular drive claimed it did.
>If you think there's an electronic problem then you don't really need an
>aligment disk. Start with the spindle speed, which I assume is right
>since it almost certainly uses a mains-powered induction motor. Still, it
>can't hurt to check that the index pulses occur at the right frequency.
>
That's all working fine... It's controller has a serious status system in it
where it monitors disk spindle speed, etc...
>They'll be a master clock, probably also used for writing. Check this
>with a 'scope or frequency counter. If it's incorrect, find out why.
>
One master clock.. 1Mhz, good.. A board dedicated to "data timing".
>Then take a formatted disk (format one yourself on your old CP/M machine
>if you have to ;-)). Read a sector continously. Display the off-disk data
>on one trace of a 'scope and the read clock on another. Does the read
>clock seem to be the right frequency? Is it locked wrt the data? If not,
>look at that read PLL (or whatever it uses).
>
Good idea on the CPM unit. I rarely use/see one so I will format one and
start that way.
>Index timing is either very important (if, for example, the controller
>expects to see an address mark as the first thing after an index pulse)
>or not at all important at this stage.
>
Not there yet.
>At this point you should at least be recovering data bits from the disk.
>So if it still can't find a sector, find out why not. Can it not find an
>address mark at all?. Or can it not find the header you're asking for.
>This is likely to be a digital problem. As I don't have schematics for
>this unit I can't comment any further.
>
It can't find a sector *most* of the time.. Once in a while I can get it to
read and display a sector correctly... The rest of the time it is in an
infinite loop.
What bugs me is sometimes I can read a sector with a good CRC and the data
is correct... probably *another* bad solder joint... this box has been
filled with them so far.
Thanks for the CP/M idea.
>-tony
>
>
>>>> >Wow. My collection of sharp objects are strictly modern
>>>>reproductions. To
>>>> >the point where I took them to the vet and had 'em xrayed to see if
>>>>they were
>>>> >correctly made. Some were, come weren't. Sold the ones that weren't.
>>>> >
>>>> >> Swords can be neat, I have a friend who recently sold a japanese
>>>>sword for
>>>> >> $40k to one of those roving sword buyers. Some local yard sale had a box
>>>>
>>>> This one was 650 years old, made by one of the best, and used in some major
>>>> ceremony. My friend estimated it will sell for 4 times as much in Japan.
>>>
>>>One wonders where your friend got the thing. I was under the impression
>>>they're
>>>illegal to export from Japan. (not sure where I got that impression though)
>>
>>Apparently a lot of swords were lost in WWII and found thier way to the US.
>>The Japanese families that lost these swords are willing to pay big bucks
>>for them if they can be found.
>
> Japanese I believe sometimes would "surrender" their swords as a formal
> gesture. GIs would also rob bodies, etc. Getting them back to Japan is a
> fair sized industry.
Wow! Quite a thread for one so far off topic.
In no particular order:
At the surrender at the end of WWII, swords were formally handed over by
commanding officers (of ships etc.) as a gesture of surrender. This is a
western custom as well as (rather than?) a Japanese one. Seems strange that
they handed over valuable antiques, but it is the sort of extravagant gesture
that goes with a culture that commits ritual suicide...
I will admit to having two swords, but I am not a collector. One is a modern
fencing foil with a rubber tip. The other, that I think of as "my sword" (even
though my brother has an interest in it) is a bit more interesting.
It is the sort of sword that officers in the Royal Navy wore with dress uniforms
up to about 1914 (when the design changed slightly). It belonged to my
grandfather, so I assume he was commissioned as a midshipman (US: ensign) at age
16 (in 1913). He may have upgraded later to the newer design, but if so, this
went to the bottom of the sea with him in 1944.
The sword was made by Wilkinson (lately of razor blade fame but in his time the
UK's leading sword manufacturer) and sold by Gieves (a well known supplier of
uniforms, known in the services as Thieves), and it bears the number (which may
be a serial number) 56500.
The test of such a sword was not whether a handkerchief would fall in two pieces
if dropped on the blade ;-) - in fact, mine has never been sharpened - but
whether you could bend the blade so that the tip would touch the forte just
below the hilt. Swords that passed would have a "proof mark" set into the blade
at that point. Wilkinsons reps used to demonstrate this, but it was said that
Gieves' swords made by anyone else, although they bore the proof mark, would be
damaged if you tried it...
My sword is somewhat corroded. I got someone to clean off the worst of the
rust; he cleaned of "as much as he dared", which unfortunately reduced the
clarity of the designs etched into the blade, so this may have been a mistake.
Nonetheless, for such a heavy piece of iron (though not relative to my computer
collection!) it is amazingly well balanced. I wouldn't have any difficulty
wielding it in a fight, even though the grip is a bit too small for me.
FWIW I am told that swords should be preserved with suitable grease. Suitable =
hydrophobic. In particular, lube oil / axle grease etc. are NOT suitable.
Petroleum jelly is recommended; I have heard of olive oil being used; and I
imagine silicone grease and some of the water displacing penetrating oils would
also work.
FWI also W I have some small skill in European fencing (although I haven't done
any for a few years now), but have never studied Kendo...
Philip.
**********************************************************************
This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and
intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they
are addressed. If you have received this email in error please notify
the system manager.
This footnote also confirms that this email message has been swept
for the presence of computer viruses.
Power Technology Centre, Ratcliffe-on-Soar,
Nottingham, NG11 0EE, UK
Tel: +44 (0)115 936 2000
http://www.powertech.co.uk
**********************************************************************