Chuck Guzis wrote:
Could someone point me to harmonic distortion data,
transient analysis or
some good old scope traces to prove that a couple of 6B4's in class A
push-pull deliver better sound than a pair of MOSFETs can?
To change the subject -- buy better speakers.
I'm not trying
to start an argument, but am not convinced that vacuum tubes are better
(having owned my share of tube amplifiers) than semiconductors.
Did I ever tell you to buy better speakers.
That is the real difference in Amps from what I have read on the net
about audio quality
is the speakers. Live music is still best but since we can't get that
getting the best value for my
$ is what I am going for. Most amps are tested with a nice 8 or 4 ohm
dummy load so they all
look the same on the scope. You barely get any specs listed nowadays but
THD so you don't
know what the amp is doing in real life. THD figures can lie as said here.
Here is stuff about harmonic distortion that I have found but it is for
tubes
mostly. See 'The Hidden Harmonics behind THD'
http://www.nutshellhifi.com/library/index.html Inter modulation is
never talked about at all.
Cheers,
Chuck
P.S. I use #16 zip cord for my speakers.
I used what was handy, but I used quality drivers and good speaker plans.
None of this Bookshelf stuff ... big heavy box that was designed for average
Hi-Fi use using full range speakers. One speaker does it all, best for
vocal stuff.
I got the lower priced Japanese stuff - $168 per pair
for the drivers. 40 to 22,000 hz @ 96 db
http://www.fostexspeakers.com/fostex.html The high end starts at $550
per pair 30 to 22,000 hz @ 103 db.
http://www.fostexspeakers.com/fostex.html
For more conventional speakers see,
http://www.nutshellhifi.com/Ariel.html .
I would like to comparisons done because I want the best sound for my $$$
so I can spend my money on music rather just have a impressive box with
tubes in it.
The links above and here
http://www.decware.com/ at least give some hard
data
in freq response and distortion and time spent tweeking the system so it
sounds
right. I have built my own mid-fi amp, with what I figure is the best
value for my money
from parts from around the world -- speakers and
resistors from Japan,
Lundahl Transformers from Sweden,
a crappy power transformer from Canada,Tubes and other stuff from USA
old stock and
surplus places like the power mosfet and zener diodes and big heat sink
and Capacitors from Japan
and France. I like data sheets and other information that is so rare in
most consumer products today.
The impressive box with blinking lights is where to spend your money,
and getting a nice
PDP-11 is something I don't expect to find handy because of shipping costs.
Ben alias woodelf