On Fri, 31 Dec 1999, Richard Erlacher wrote:
GAWD! That's really a confusing mess! I always
thought WD got its
board-level products badly mixed up number-wise, but this is beyond what I'd
feared.
I have two flavors of 1007, which are definitely ESDI, only one 1006, though
it's the MFM version, no EPROM, but I did at one time have a 1005 which was
definitely for ESDI and a 1006 which had the RLL chips (5xxx-series) and
turned the MFM drive into an RLL easily enough.
Reviewing the listing from TheRef, I find that the HDCs divide like
this: 1001, 1002, 1003, 1004, and 1006 are all ST412 interface
1005, 1007, and 1009 are all ESDI interface.
Within the ST412 grouping are both MFM and RLL controllers. There is
only one version of the 1005, but multiple versions of the 1007 and
1009.
Note that I delimited the above to HDCs to avoid addressing the 1002-FOX
FDC!
- don
...and I thought the bridge controller boards were
badly numbered!
Dick
-----Original Message-----
From: Allison J Parent <allisonp(a)world.std.com>
To: Discussion re-collecting of classic computers
<classiccmp(a)u.washington.edu>
Date: Friday, December 31, 1999 10:07 AM
Subject: Re: how many heads, Cylinders on a Quantum 540?
<No offense, Allison, but the 1007 and 1005
controllers won't work with tha
<drive at all, as both 1005 and 1007 are ESDI controllers. You may be
<thinking of the 1006's which come in both MFM and RLL. The 1006 WITH an
<EPROM on it is the RLL version, while the MFM version uses the
<motherboard-resident BIOS to handle the HDD.
I could be off on the 1007 though I have NO edsi drives and am using 1005
and WD1007 (least that what the markings are) and both are PC using D540s.
Also my 1006 was used with them in the current system before I went IDE.
Note we may be talking across part numbers as I have three 1005s that
are each decidedly different from each other yet, the primary part of the
part number is WD1005! I also have 4 flavors of 1002, three differnt
lengths, one surface mount! Of all the PC controllers from WDC I have
about ten, starting with the 1002 also the 1003, 1005, 1006 and 1007.
The only EDSI controller I have is a non WD design and I don't ahve drives
for that.
<ESDI is a high-level interface not at all like the "ultra-dumb"
<ST-506/ST-412 interface this drive claims to have, though it does use
cable
<of similar configuration, hence has similar
connectors.
Ah, I do know the difference.
<This drive is commonly used with MFM, though its speed control, etc, is
<capable of RLL densities as are most "MFM" drives.
I've found it to be more successful than others though RD53s (micropolus
1325s 71mb) were really nice at 100mb RLL and pretty reliable till they got
old.
Allison