Dave McGuire ????????:
On Jan 22, 2010, at 5:24 PM, js at
cimmeri.com wrote:
mu?se?um (my?-z???m) n. Abbr. mus. 1. A building,
place, or
institution devoted to the acquisition, conservation, study,
exhibition, and educational interpretation of objects having
scientific, historical, or artistic value. {American Heritage}
By this def, Robert's home (a "place") and website qualify
collectively as a modest museum. I think it's better to argue over
the aspects of his museum -- such as quality, size, rank amongst
others, etc -- rather than what word Robert has likely casually
ascribed to his purpose.
We're squabbling over the definition of terms which are changing over
time. Web sites didn't exist when the definition above was written.
Things change!
It was once in fashion to call certain websites "virtual museums".
Not mentioned in the American Heritage Dictionary's definition, but
certainly part of the commonly accepted definition, if not description
of a museum is that it is generally open to the public. For museums
which are private and closed to the public, the term "private
collection" tended to be used. By the broadest definition so far
discussed, any collection of anything could be referred to as a
musuem, including Jay Leno's car collection, various coin and stamp
collections, pop-top tab collections, and even someone's collection of
used kleenex, and it need not be open to the public.
But these times they are a-changin', and so are languages, not the
least of which is English. By the time a dictionary is printed it's
obsolete. Even the OED, which is the most up-to-date (and exhaustively
thorough) dictionary, is unable to keep itself abreast of current word
usage: It's always at least months or even a year behind.
Since it has become possible to publicly display and share a private
collection via a "virtual museum" website, and there is a tendency to
simplify language, it is not surprising that the word "virtual" is
being dropped and only "museum" used. So the argument about what
constitutes a museum is, or will shortly be, moot. No?
==
jd
The penalty for laughing in a courtroom is six months in jail; if it
were not for this penalty, the jury would never hear the evidence.
-- H. L. Mencken
--