2 Nov
2012
2 Nov
'12
11:44 a.m.
On 11/02/2012 01:55 PM, Jim Brain wrote:
Is there a document or link that explains why this
type of station is
better than a Weller-type unit (WESD-51 here)?
I don't know of any documents or links, but I've used them
side-by-side, I prefer the Metcal.
I still have a Weller, though (on a different bench) and I don't gnash
my teeth when I use it. I notice the differences, but I will NOT say
"Wellers suck".
I know in this gang I'd have to publish it in a book for it to be
considered legitimate information, but enough people ask me for
soldering advice that I feel comfortable considering myself to be fairly
knowledgeable about it.
I mean, I have no complaints with my Weller, but I am
doing more SMT
work as of late, and maybe I should upgrade.
In my experience, most Wellers are very good irons. Most Hakkos are
very very good irons. Metcals are great irons.
That said, if you're comfortable with what you're using, don't
consider it broken. Different people use their tools in different ways.
It's probably worth the time to try a Metcal to see if YOU notice a
significant difference...if you don't, then upgrading is a waste of
money, time, and effort becoming accustomed to a different tool.
-Dave
--
Dave McGuire, AK4HZ
New Kensington, PA