-----Original Message-----
From: cclist at
sydex.com
Sent: Sun, 07 Aug 2011 14:37:54 -0700
To: cctalk at
classiccmp.org
Subject: RE: Wintel box vs. terminal WAS: cctech Digest, Vol 96, Issue 5
On 7 Aug 2011 at 22:13, arcarlini at
iee.org wrote:
Rob Jarratt quoted and wrote:
>
>> Sure there are complicted terminals, but be honest. Which would
>> you rather fix : A VT100 or a modern Wintel PC?
>>
>
> Answer: A modern Wintel PC: I can just go to one of any
> number of shops and buy a replacement part :-)
I think you may have missed the word
"fix" in there. You may consider
the modern wintel box to be a disposable tool, but Tony doesn't.
Well, most modern Wintel boxes use fine-pitch BGA packages. While
it's possible to remove and re-ball such stuff, it's not something I
care to waste my time doing.
Slightly vintage Wintel boxes can be had for the asking and it really
makes no sense to run a multi-core speed demon to emulate a terminal.
The last time I needed a standalone text terminal, I just built one
from a uC, a MAX232, a wall wart and a PC keyboard. I could have
put the entire thing but for the monitor in the keyboard housing.
Complete terminal makings can be found in any moderately-well-stocked
hellbox.
--Chuck
While all of these things may be true, I really like the idea of using
purpose-built tools for the task at hand. In this case, I can think
of a couple of reasons why I would prefer a dedicated terminal over
a PeeCee:
1. Typically very nice font rendering on analog CRT's made for use
with the terminal. I'm particularly fond of AMBER screen phosphors.
2. Easily adjustable contrast/brightness (two knobs, usually).
3. I don't ever recall a terminal crashing
4. No waiting for boot-up for $OS_DEJURE
5. Dedicated terminals are usually smaller, lighter, easier to handle
physically, unless you're considering 'thin-client' PeeCees of course.
The dedicated data terminal is a simple machine, to do a simple task,
with alot of utility. My favorite being the WY-50, as it emulates
many kinds of commonly-used terminals, comes in amber, and overall
is easy to use.
just my $0.02
____________________________________________________________
Publish your photos in seconds for FREE
TRY IM TOOLPACK at