In article <50F33642.5070405 at gmail.com>,
Josh Dersch <derschjo at gmail.com> writes:
On 1/13/2013 1:11 PM, Dave McGuire wrote:
Were
there any PDP-11 graphics systems that actually had a memory-mapped
framebuffer?
Yes, the AED 512 and 767 have a Qbus interface that (I believe) uses
DMA, in addition to the standard RS232 port.
Cool. And I misspoke -- the QRGB-GRAPH does support DMA, so it might be
fast enough for DOOM after all :).
See
<http://bitsavers.trailing-edge.com/pdf/aed/AED_1024/990024-01B_Model_1024_Color_Graphics_Terminal_User's_Manual.pdf>
However, DMA != memory-mapped.
Memory-mapped means the pixel changes as soon as I diddle the bits and
the next refresh cycle comes around. Memory-mapped means the CPU can
determine the contents of a pixel by reading a memory location.
DMA means a chunk of host memory can be transmitted to the device
while the CPU is doing some other task. The AED 512/617/1024 can
interface to a host machine by means of a parallel interface with DMA
capability. While this is certainly faster than using a serial
interface and an ASCII command stream, it is by no means as fast as a
memory-mapped display. There is no abaility for the AED to send data
back to the host over the DMA interface, it is unidirectional. The
above PDF says the bandwidth is 3 MB/s across the DMA interface.
At 800x600 256 color VGA mode, refreshed at 30 Hz, DOOM uses:
800*600*30/1024/1024 = 13 MB/sec
I believe DOOM actually goes at 60 Hz, not 30, so it's even worse.
However, 30 Hz is generally considered the minimum for interactive
real-time graphics.
Assuming using the maximum 3 MB/sec bandwidth of the AED and 4 bits/pixel
instead of 8, gives you enough bandwidth to do 512x384 (4:3 aspect ratio).
The AED actually stores 8bpp, so I'd have to dig further into the docs
to see if you could transmit 4bpp and have it locally expand that to
8; you probably can with some downloaded microcode (i.e. 6502 assembly
language). That's a calculation based purely on the DMA speed listed
in the document, you'd have to do an actual end-to-end analysis to see
how fast you could update the AEd from a Qbus PDP-11; the DMA transfer
rate may not be the limiting factor.
--
"The Direct3D Graphics Pipeline" free book
<http://tinyurl.com/d3d-pipeline>
The Computer Graphics Museum <http://computergraphicsmuseum.org>
The Terminals Wiki <http://terminals.classiccmp.org>
Legalize Adulthood! (my blog) <http://legalizeadulthood.wordpress.com>