Evan Koblentz wrote:
This was an issue a couple of years ago. Now it's
back: the 10,000-word
article that I published on my personal web site in 2005 (and since took
down) is reprint IN FULL at
http://www.iranianpda.com/iPDADB/FAQs/PDAHistory/ThehistoryofPDAs.htm,
obviously without my permission. Whatever moron did this even included my
disclaimer saying not to steal my work!!!
Looking at the source, it's an exact copy -- even the "return to
homepage" goes to your site, not theirs. I don't read Iranian, but that
doesn't seem like stealing/plagiarism (ie. trying to pass the content
off as their own), but rather mirroring the content. You also wrote on
the page "please don't reprint anything without crediting me" -- they
are indeed crediting you as your byline is intact. So is this stealing?
I'm curious: Do you consider a 100% exact mirror, with all authorship
notices intact, stealing?
You use the word "republishing" but apply it to online non-commercial
content, which I don't understand. Can you clarify that? What is
"republishing" as applied to online content?
I'm not trying to start a war; I'm honestly interested in the answers
because they have relevance to archiving our hobby (more specifically,
putting said archives online).
--
Jim Leonard (trixter at
oldskool.org)
http://www.oldskool.org/
Help our electronic games project:
http://www.mobygames.com/
Or check out some trippy MindCandy at
http://www.mindcandydvd.com/
A child borne of the home computer wars:
http://trixter.wordpress.com/