On Mar 27, 2012, at 3:56 PM, Tony Duell wrote:
Do you _seriously_ believe that buying the amount of
rosewood to make a
cover for one straight-8 will make any difference to the rate of
destruction of said forest?
I'm late to all this, because my Internet has been out all weekend, but
yes. If you buy it new, you are contributing a lot more than you think,
because you are one more data point confirming the existence of a market
out there for the foresters. It's not entirely dissimilar to elephant
ivory and poaching; no, buying one or two little trinkets made of ivory
doesn't mean you've personally shot an elephant for a fraction of its
tusks, but it does produce a perceived demand. It's not like someone
registers an interest in some wood and a logger goes out and chops down
a tree for them; there are frightening differential equations that can
describe these markets and how the suppliers attempt to keep up with
and anticipate demand.
Also, depending on where you get your recycled rosewood, you could be
doing the same thing if you're not getting it from people who are very
specifically trying to quell the overconsumption of rare woods, because
you're still indicating a demand in rosewood.
Honestly, the argument that "I'm only taking a little, and there are few
enough straight-8s in the world to ever make a difference" is foolish on
its face. I'd expect better from the members of this list, because
you're all quite smart enough to understand the complexities involved in
an interconnected, byzantine system like this.
Short answer: get it recycled if you must, or from a sustainable farm.
After all, we all seem to get our computers "recycled", no?
- Dave