From: Mark J. Blair
Where is the modified Unibus used? ... I tried to cram
in every bus I
could find using the same physical form factor, but if MUD is an
especially niche application then maybe it doesn't need to be in there.
From: David Riley fraveydank at
gmail.com
Typical Unibus peripherals are quad-width; those that
are hex-width are
*generally* only in it for the additional power .. There are certainly
exceptions, but I don't know what they are.
If someone is trying to build Unibus memory, they'll probably be
interested in the modified Unibus pins. Otherwise, it's somewhat
unlikely.
I'm on the road, and away from my documentation, but I definitely would not
call MUD 'niche' - it's pretty much the standard hex-height UNIBUS spec in
all the later UNIBUS backplanes.
Here's what I can recall: in the beginning, there were what were called
'Small Peripheral Controller' (SPC) slots, which took quad-high cards in the
C-F connectors. Older, simpler interfaces (think DL11, RX01/2 controllers,
etc) were quad cards which went in the C-F connectors of an SPC slot. (More
complicated interfaces, like the RK11, RP11, DH11 etc were entire custom
backplanes/system units - 4 slot for the RK11, larger for the DH11, IIRC.)
I forget what was in the top two connectors (A-B) of the old SPC slots (e.g.
on the early DD11s - the name of the early 4-slot backplane units). Of
course, in the 1 and 4 slots, the A and B connectors had 'standard UNIBUS' so
one could plug in either a jumper module to the next backplane (earlier M920,
later M9202 - once they started dealing with lumped loads), or a UNIBUS cable
(the big flat white one) to another system unit.
So then hex cards started to become common (and basically all later UNIBUS
interface cards are hex cards - from early ones like the DZ11 and RL11, to
the latest ones like the UDA50, DELUA, etc). Around then, the MUD spec came
in: in a MUD slot, the bottom 4 connectors (C-F) are still SPC (so you can
plug any quad SPC board into the C-D connectors of a MUD slot), but the top
two connectors (A-B) are subtly different.
I _think_ many (most?) hex boards are MUD only, but I would have to check on
that.
When I get back, I will check and see what the A-B connectors in an old SPC
slot are - and if any hex UNIBUS cards use that, instead of MUD. (Of course,
any hex card that _only_ uses SPC pins can go in either kind. I don't know if
there are any hex cards are like that - or perhaps many are, I just don't
know off the top of my head.)
From: David Riley
Qbus shares Unibus' defined +5v and GND pins and
adds a few more
dedicated grounds ... I'm honestly a little surprised they didn't make
the power pins a little more broadly compatible (or at least less
likely to cause damage) in general
Well, I can kinda-sorta understand the UNIBUS and QBUS not being safe from
each other. It's sort of 'intuitively obvious' that one shouldn't plug a
card
from one into the other. (And remember, the QBUS
started out as almost all
dual-high cards, except the LSI-11 CPU card, another
differentiation.)
But the Q/Q and Q/CD thing is, to me, at least, different - one has to
know there are two kinds of QBUS, and not to plug cards for one into
the other (except the many cards that can go both ways).
But now that I think about it, I guess there are sorta two kinds of UNIBUS
too - MUD and non-MUD. And I think I even recall someone damaging a card by
plugging a non-MUD card into a MUD slot (or vice versa, I don't recall the
details any more).
Noel