Richard writes:
This isn't the first time someone has made a slam
on packing peanuts,
yet I've had plenty of things sent and recieved with peanuts and had
no problems. I think the key is to not just dump the peanuts into the
container, but to physically compress them into the box. The flaps of
the box should require some pressure to fully close around the item.
If done properly, peanuts will not leave a loose void for things to
wiggle around inside.
I think your comments are perfectly valid for the sorts of things
that ship well with peanuts. There's even different types of peanuts
that work well for different densities of items etc.
But they do not work well for dense, heavy items with protrusions
that have to be protected. Foam-in-place has a real advantage in
keeping the object centered in the middle of the box - compressed
peanuts work sometimes but foam-in-place works all the time. And some
"handcrafting" with custom wooden or cardboard corner protectors,
bubble wrap of appropriate type (some times are best for lightweight
items and others will stand the abuse of heavy items) cleverly applied,
or even newspaper/kraft paper PROPERLY used
can do a remarkable job making sure that it's not the protrusions
or corners that hit the edge of the box.
It's not so much the peanuts I'm opposed to, they are valuable and
sometimes appropriate tools. It's the attitude that throwing a
70 pound, very dense instrument with fragile protrusions into
a cardboard box with peanuts around it is the best or only thing
that can be done.
What's astonishing is that 80% of the time when an instrument
was damaged in transit, it was packaged by the "UPS store"
or equivalent. You'd think that since they're charging for their
services they might actually use UPS-recommended supplies
and techniques, but they don't!
Tim.