On Sun, 18 Jun 2000, Tony Duell wrote:
HP were fond of suggesting that you do this :-(, even
on machines where
the PSU could easily fail in a way that the 5V output went up to a very
high level (like 30V!) I often wondered if it was to sell more CPU boards
;-).
Zog! Why can't they build power supplies with a dummy load built in, or at
least a dummy load and a "test" switch so that the dummy load isn't
attached
to the output when the computer is?
Just to be on
the safe side, I'll try it out of the computer first if
it will work with no load just to make sure that there aren't any bad
Be warned that a lot of HP PSUs of the early 1970's vintage (at least)
don't like being run with no load. I normally load them with a 6V 5W or
6V 21W bulb (depending on the rating of the PSU) before turning them on.
I'll try to find a bulb to use. Is it only the 5V supply that has to be
loaded? I've got a resistor that was used for loading a Sun shoebox with
a tape drive and no PSU; I wonder if that would work. I'll have to see
what value it is; about a 10W resistor, IIRC.
Of course, if the PSU has no lose bits in it, and has already been
turned on by someone else before I got it, hasn't any damage that's
going to be done already been done? Hopefully I'll not get LARTed for
asking this, but, how likely am I to do any additional damage at this
point by turning it on attached to the sytem and checking the
voltages?
Some service manuals warn (in bold printing) against
running the PSU
board with no load (it may even imply that the only load you can use is
the CPU board!). I have never tried to run a PSU like that unloaded, so I
have no idea what would happen, but I can't think it would be a good idea.
Thanks for the warning!
really going on and work out my own set of tests.
Mainly because I then
understand what I am measuring and can make valid deductions if (for
example) I see a very odd voltage or waveform at a particular point.
Makes sense; after all, that's what schematics are for, or, don't
people know how to read them these days? Alas, I don't have a set of
schematics, and will have to settle for whatever info. I can get from
someone who has any troubleshooting information - within reason, of
course.
For much the same reason I've never found
signature analysis to be a
particularly useful technique.
What's signature analysis?
--
R. D. Davis
rdd(a)perqlogic.com
http://www.perqlogic.com/rdd
410-744-4900