From: "Chuck Guzis" <cclist at sydex.com>
Subject: Re: New DEC museum entry :D
<snip>
And a question for the US experts. On a 120v circuit,
will a $6.00
GFI detect a leak between neutral and ground? Or is the detection
circuitry only on the high side of the line?
As mentioned by several others, GF(C)Is detect an imbalance between
hot and neutral and do not in fact care about ground at all. Since the
neutral is normally bonded to ground at the main panel, it would require
considerable current in the neutral to generate a detectable voltage
difference between neutral and ground at the receptacle; in the unlikely
event that the neutral is not at ground potential a GFCI would still trip
on a fault.
In fact, if you have to replace one of the unobtainium 2-prong ungrounded
receptacles in an old house wired with knob & tube (or the '50s era 2-wire NM
non-metallic sheathed), replacing it with a GFCI receptacle will give protection
similar to a grounded outlet (although of course running a ground wire back to
the panel is preferable, since an internal short or leakage will not be detected
until there is an external path to ground, and noise suppression filters will be
ineffective).
The "bedroom GFCI"s that Ethan mentioned are actually Arc-fault interrrupters,
required by most jurisdictions for the last 4 or 5 years in bedroom circuits
because neither a circuit breaker nor a GFCI will trip on an arcing short or
connection (the cause of many if not most residential electrical fires) if the
current is less than the breaker rating.
mike