Subject: Re: newbie building a scratch-built computer
From: Dave McGuire <mcguire at neurotica.com>
Date: Sun, 05 Aug 2007 14:54:42 -0400
To: "General Discussion: On-Topic Posts Only" <cctech at
classiccmp.org>
On Aug 5, 2007, at 4:16 AM, Gordon JC Pearce wrote:
Not the
best choice, IMHO, a better one you might find at
www.willem.org.
There are commercial clones as well, like the one from
www.silvotronic.de
(board, kit available through ePay for instance). I have bought a
kit from
them and they work fine.
One caveat with the willem programmers is that there really is only
Windows software available for them. It works well under Wine with a
bit of messing about.
That in itself is a good reason to avoid them, in my opinion. I
have two or three useless PC-based EPROM programmers sitting in
various boxes in the garage. They're useless because the
manufacturer has orphaned them (or just plain gone out of business)
and I either lost the software, or it only runs under some release of
Windows that isn't easily available anymore. (and I'll be damned if
I'm going to have a Windows machine here just to run an EPROM
programmer!)
Anything worth doing is worth doing right. Get a standalone
device programmer, not one that pretends to be a computer
peripheral...or worse yet, a "Windows PC peripheral". With a real
device programmer, you won't get locked into the whims of the
manufacturer (at least not as easily), or worse yet, the whims of
Microsoft. Having an important tool depend on an unreliably,
proprietary operating system from one manufacturer who is well-known
for sleazy business practices sure doesn't sound to me like a smart
way to run.
I used a Data I/O 2900 for many years, and I absolutely loved it.
I recently replaced it with a Data I/O Unisite...a big beefy one with
a hard drive. It's Good Stuff(tm) and can program pretty much
anything. When designing or repairing something, I never have to
stop and worry about whether or not I can program a particular
device. These machines have floppy drives, and can deal with DOS-
formatted disks (which most anything can write) and understand
literally dozens of different file formats. They can also be
remotely controlled via a *STANDARD* serial port, and the protocol is
simple and openly documented.
Like I said...anything worth doing is worth doing right.
DataIO is nice but if you don't have one the next best is anything that
has an interface that is easily coded for or the code is available.
I use a S100 Prommer and have the sources so the end result was a
SBC880, RAM-17 and an old 4slot mother using a PC power supply to
make a dedicated programmer with a serial port to any host. The
nice part about Eproms is they are standardized.
Allison