"Bill Sudbrink" <wh.sudbrink at verizon.net> wrote:
I have always found it interesting how quickly people
will go chopping
up circuit boards. Before you do this, consider chopping up a ribbon
cable instead. Ribbon cables are cheap and easy to replace if you
later change to a different make of drive or if you simply screw up
making the modification. I run SA-851's on my 16FDC with a simply
modified ribbon cable.
I have always found it interesting how quickly people comment on issues
without first studying them in depth. :-)
The TG43 signal is entirely absent from the 16FDC drive connector and no
cable mod alone can correct that. The board modification brings the signal
from the FDC1793 through a driver to the connector so
that a cable can
carry it to the drive. If you choose to operate the SA-851 out of
spec, it
is certainly your right. I chose to make my 16FDC compatible with the
drive's operating requirements.
Incidentally, the Shugart SA-800/801 doesn't require TG43 and will work
with just a cable mod (or maybe no mod at all since that drive is single
sided). Almost every newer drive, including SA-851, however, will have
higher error rates on the inner cylinders without the reduced write current
controlled by TG43.