---------Original Messages:
From: dm561 at
torfree.net
To: cctalk at
classiccmp.org
Date: Sun, 25 Nov 2007 06:44:14 -0500
Subject: RE: FD400 drive troubleshooting
<snip>
>>> Which just happens to be the ratio of
300RPM vs 360RPM, so that on a 300RPM
>>> strobe disk w/a 60Hz light the 60Hz bars = 300RPM and the 50Hz bars =
360RPM.
> Hi
> I think you have the ratio backward. The 60 Hz disk for 360 RPM
> can be used for the 50 Hz 300 RPM.
> Dwight
<snip>
Hi
I guess my problem was reading your sentence. It just isn't clear
to me where you are saying they are equal and where they are not.
The part "60Hz bars = 300RPM and the 50Hz bars = 360RPM" seems
to be saying that "300RPM @ 60Hz = 360RPM @ 50Hz".
I'm sure I'm reading it wrong but it is still confusing. At least
we both agree on the basics and that is all that counts.
Dwight
--------Reply:
Well, I did say "the 60 and 50Hz *BARS*" (as in "stripe" or
"band") at the same
frequency of illumination (60Hz), but perhaps I should have inserted "the speed
at which the bars seem to stop" instead of trying to keep it short and simple
(with exactly the opposite effect).
OK, how about this:
It just so happens that the ratio of 360RPM to 300RPM is the same as 60Hz to 50Hz.
Therefore, if you have a strobe disk for a 300RPM drive with both 50Hz and 60Hz bars
on it and a 60Hz source of illumination, then you can use the same disk to check the
speed of a 360RPM drive, since at 360RPM the 50Hz bars will appear to be stationary.
I'm talking about using a 300RPM disk at 60Hz (for the OP and others trying to check
the speed of a 360RPM FD400 or equivalent with 60Hz); you seem to be talking about
using a 360RPM strobe disk (if you found one) at 50Hz, a somewhat different situation
albeit one taking advantage of the same "coincidence".
But I think by now both our points have been made abundantly and painfully clear, and
I'm glad that we can finally put it to rest and not clutter up the archives further.
m