12 Feb
2004
12 Feb
'04
9:50 a.m.
Hi All,
Just a thought. Did anyone ever try to connect DVD drives,
or CDROM changers, to VAX-class machines, such as 3100's or
InfoServers?
I *would* assume InfoServer cant handle the DVD data format,
although newer VMS systems might. How do they deal with
multiple-LUN devices such as changers?
Cheers,
Fred
--
Fred N. van Kempen, DEC (Digital Equipment Corporation) Collector/Archivist
Visit the VAXlab Project at http://VAXlab.pdp11.nl/
Visit the Archives at http://www.pdp11.nl/
Email: waltje(a)pdp11.nl BUSSUM, THE NETHERLANDS / Mountain View, CA, USA
12 Feb
12 Feb
10:02 a.m.
Problem I've run into is that the older vax'es don't play well with many
non-Dec CD-ROM drives due to a firmware issue and I've had to go out and
hunt a real DEC cd-rom.... the Alpha's are far more flexible and play
well with more common parts.
Certain Toshiba cd-roms and vaxes get along nicely, I had an older NEC
multispin work on a Microvax II at one point if I recall.... DVD's
would only be viewed as cd-roms if you could get them to be accessible
at all.... if you've got a nice supply of drives to tinker with, its
worth doing some trial and error research.
Curt
Curt
Fred N. van Kempen wrote:
Hi All,
Just a thought. Did anyone ever try to connect DVD drives,
or CDROM changers, to VAX-class machines, such as 3100's or
InfoServers?
I *would* assume InfoServer cant handle the DVD data format,
although newer VMS systems might. How do they deal with
multiple-LUN devices such as changers?
Cheers,
Fred
--
Curt Vendel & Karl Morris
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
The Atari Museum
http://www.atarimuseum.com
The Atari Explorer
http://www.atari-explorer.com
10:30 a.m.
On Thu, 12 Feb 2004, Curt Vendel wrote:
Problem I've run into is that the older vax'es
don't play well with many
non-Dec CD-ROM drives due to a firmware issue and I've had to go out and
hunt a real DEC cd-rom.... the Alpha's are far more flexible and play
well with more common parts.
True, although I have had success with most of the
drives I ended
up with.
Certain Toshiba cd-roms and vaxes get along nicely, I
had an older NEC
multispin work on a Microvax II at one point if I recall.... DVD's
would only be viewed as cd-roms if you could get them to be accessible
at all.... if you've got a nice supply of drives to tinker with, its
worth doing some trial and error research.
Yeah, I have about, hrrm, oh, 200 drives
splattered across the
place, so I can play. I *know* that most NEC, Toshiba and all
of the Plextor drives are OK. Most older CD-writers are, too.
I have a box of JVC DVD players, I will probably hook em up to
an 3100 and see what happens... likewise for the Nakamichi CD
changers.
(it will be fun to set up an 3100 with 2 SCSI channels as an
InfoServer, with 2 external towers loaded with Nakamichi CD
changers and a couple DVD drives... ;-)
--f
11:18 a.m.
Certain
Toshiba cd-roms and vaxes get along nicely, I had
an older NEC
multispin work on a Microvax II at one point if
I
recall.... DVD's
would only be viewed as cd-roms if you could get
them to be
accessible
at all.... if you've got a nice supply of
drives to
tinker with, its
worth doing some trial and error research.
Yeah, I have about, hrrm, oh, 200 drives splattered across
the place, so I can play. I *know* that most NEC, Toshiba
and all of the Plextor drives are OK. Most older CD-writers are, too. I have a box of JVC DVD players, I will probably hook
em up
to an 3100 and see what happens... likewise for the Nakamichi
CD changers.
Changes usually appear as sub-luns don't they? If so, then
I think the OpenVMS driver can cope (that is, IIRC, why the
naming convention is as it is - to allow for this very
possibility). Let us know whether ESS sees multiple
drives or not.
Antonio
--
---------------
Antonio Carlini arcarlini(a)iee.org
11:47 a.m.
-----Original Message-----
From: cctalk-bounces(a)classiccmp.org
[mailto:cctalk-bounces@classiccmp.org] On Behalf Of Antonio Carlini
Sent: 12 February 2004 16:18
To: 'General Discussion: On-Topic and Off-Topic Posts'
Subject: RE: DEC question: DVD drives and/or CDROM changers
I've never tried a non-DEC CDROM (never had to) but I do have
a Yamaha CDRW which no longer writes, so I may try it out
sometime. If it can be persuaded to do 512-byte blocks it
will work, if it can't, it probably won't. The other rule of
thumb is that if it works on Sun it probably works on a VAX
(and vice-versa).
When I first read this I thought you were quoting me from the other day, but
I think that was in a private mail :) I tried such a thing with a Yamaha
CDRW 4416S that no longer writes yesterday and it hung the bus - wouldn't
even self test :-/
Then I remembered I had an RRD43 kicking around so at least the install was
twice as quick....
Cheers
--
Adrian/Witchy
Owner & Webmaster, Binary Dinosaurs
www.binarydinosaurs.co.uk - possibly the UK's biggest online computer museum
www.snakebiteandblack.co.uk - ex-monthly gothic shenanigans :o(
7744
days inactive
7744
days old
4 comments
4 participants
participants (4)
-
arcarlini＠iee.org -
curt＠atarimuseum.com -
waltje＠pdp11.nl -
witchy＠binarydinosaurs.co.uk