On Tue, 13 Dec 2005 07:41:29 -0500
Allison <ajp166 at bellatlantic.net> wrote:
Subject: Re: Copyright -- was PC-DOS 3.3
From: "Chuck Guzis" <cclist at sydex.com>
Date: Mon, 12 Dec 2005 21:42:13 -0800
To: cctalk at
classiccmp.org
On 12/13/2005 at 12:24 AM 9000 VAX wrote:
One question. I often can find old abandoned
PC's. Most of
them are >with software. Am I authorized to use the software
I
found? One step >further, could I copy them to my own PC and
use them? Examples are MKS >tool kit, MS C 6.0, several
versions of DOS, Qedit, PC tools. I admit >that I am not
bothered by this issue. I am just curious about the >'main
stream' opinion.
I suppose that would depend on the EULA, wouldn't it? Some
permit transfer of license with or without charge, others
don't.
The MS EULA is simple. If the machine dies and you pitch it you
supposed to buy everything new. You may however repair it, for
whatever that really amounts to. They want you to spend,
spend, spend.
Some people, like myself, have gone out of the way to purchase
'retail box' editions of Microsoft Operating Systems. They cost
considerably more than the 'OEM' version or the 'Upgrade' version,
but in many instances they WERE (and are) available. The owner of
a retail-box edition of Windows 98, for instance, is entitled for
perpetuity to run that software on any single machine. Windows 98
'retail box' 'for systems without a Windows operating system' was
$189 instead of the $89 for an 'upgrade' copy, and the two
packages were sold beside each other on the same retail shelf.
And OEM versions, if purchased at a 'screwdriver shop' type
operation, and not bundled with a specific machine from Compaq or
Dell, are 'bound' to whatever piece of hardware they were
purchased with. I don't know that it's been tested in court, but
if I buy an OEM edition of Windows 2000 at a computer store
bundled with a SIMM or a Hard Drive, which DOES (or did, anyway)
satisfy Microsoft's OEM requirement, you could probably just tape
that SIMM inside your new machine and continue to use the
software. Or use it in some 'vital' capacity, i.e. as a spacer
that keeps the hard drive from slipping down loosely in the case.
I once purchased a new-old-stock 5-1/4" full-height 9GB SCSI hard
drive from an ebay seller. He threw in a new shrink-wrapped copy
of Office 97 without even telling me beforehand that it would be
included. This was shortly after Office 2000 had come out, and
Office 97 was still (and still is) a viable useful piece of
software. It was a nice surprise and I had no idea that the
software was going to be 'thrown in' on the deal (there was no
mention of it on the bid page.)
People get software all the time like that with laptops, etc.