> Recycled
styrofoam wrapped in aluminum foil works for me and is
> practically free...
That offers no ESD protection whatsoever.
I think "no...whatsoever" is an exaggeration, though it certainly isn't
as good as proper antistatic foam.
Aluminum foil is a great conductor of static
electricity [...]
That's why it helps. The danger is not high voltage relative to some
arbitrary ground; the danger is high voltage between elements of the
chip, mostly meaning between pins. That means that a low-impedance
path joining all pins will reduce the risk of static damage.
Not eliminate it, both because the path is not perfect - it's got
nonzero impedance at best and thus can develop voltage between pins -
and because it's possible, especially after longer-term storage, for
the aluminum foil to develop holes large enough to break contact with
the pins. But then, those are true of conductive foam, too; indeed,
because its resistance is much higher, it is less protective against a
static jolt delivered directly to a chip pin. (What it _is_ much more
protective against is a jolt delivered to the foam.)
The pink bags are exactly the same way, they
aren't static
dissipative and don't protect sensitive electronics,
Some of them are. I've seen pink plastic bags that were conductive to
antistatic levels - they simply would not hold a charge no matter how
hard I tried and how well something less conductive, like a shopping
bag or a more ordinary plastic bag, would hold a charge under similar
circumstances.
I do, of course, agree that it's not wise to count on a bag to be
antistatic just because it's pink. :-)
/~\ The ASCII Mouse
\ / Ribbon Campaign
X Against HTML mouse at
rodents-montreal.org
/ \ Email! 7D C8 61 52 5D E7 2D 39 4E F1 31 3E E8 B3 27 4B