it is a REALLY
REALLY REALLY bad idea to just power old removable disk
drives up to see if they will 'just work'
as you discovered, THEY DON'T, and destroy themselves in the process
Yes....
:-(
look at the
messages from Tom Jennings about all the trouble he had
getting his going over the past few months
Hmpf, I forgot. Yes, he had some
trouble with his Nova...
Umm yeah, don't do what I did... and I was even vaguely paying
attention.
that is most
likely unrepairable unless you are VERY lucky and can
clean the heads
Are there any tricks beyond Isopropanol?
YES -- it is an extremely Big Deal to clean the heads on drives
that have been sitting for a period of time greater than their
design life! THat was the mistake I made. I did an ordinary clean
job, which was grossly inadequate.
DONT POWER IT ON AGAIN. If you crashed the removable platter you
don't have a total disaster, just a small one. The media is now no
good, 99.99% certainty. The heads are probably OK, assuming they
were not physically damaged some time in the last decades.
I found that counter to advice I had to remove the heads from the
drive and do an extraordinary cleaning job with a 10X magnifier.
THere was FeO practically fused to the head ceramic. I used a
piece of wood ("popsicle stick" aka craft stick) soaked in
alcohol, under a magnifier, to physically remove scrape off the
oxide blobs. Nothing less worked, including soaking the head face
in 99% alcohol.
You will need factory technical documentation to do this. Head
removal/insertion is rather delicate. One slip (eg. the pair of
heads, which are under spring tension towards the platter) and the
ceramic-faced heads >>WHACK<< together, ruining the heads
permanently and immediately. And so on. It'll all be covered in
the factory docs.
I'd rate this a difficult job (eg. high skill level) but it can be
done; field service monkeys changed heads all the time. Just
gotta have docs, go slow, be patient, and use the right tools.
That said, the biggest problem will then be, upon reassembly, the
heads will be out of alignment with the pack(s) and you will need
to align them. This is a Big Deal and cannot be done without an
oscilloscpe and again the legendary factory documentation
(schematics, etc).
There is another solution to the problem which I took -- reformat
the media. Of course this means instantaneous data loss.
For the fixed platter, if you don't need the contents (eg. you can
reinstall from other media) it's a fine solution. For removable
media though it's a bad idea unless you're willing to abandon pack
interchangability with other disk drives. I did give this up!
I have only one removable pack; I don't need portability. If it
ever comes up in a serious way, then I'll align the heads. I just
didn't feel like undertaking it then. It would mean of course the
pack I'm usnig now would have to be reformatted, but that's not a
big deal for me.
(My drive then died from another electronic failure, about a month
later, which I have yet to fix.)
If you crash the fixed head, you're screwed unless you can do a
platterectomy and replace it. I was able to do this with EXTREME
EXTREME CARE, using the platter from a removable pack (hence my
lack of spares).
I have a few others.... Perhaps the drive has crashed
before. Because one of
the packs is open and the disk has these nice concentric stripes....
The media should be utterly perfect and smooth brown oxide. If you
see aluminum, it's hopelessly crashed. Now you could have worn but
usable media, where the oxide is discolored or optically
discontinuous; what happens is dirt/crud on the head, within
non-crash limits, reaches through the air film of the spinning
platter and bonks off the peaks of the (micro) mountains of oxide
on the platter. It'll take the gloss off... these kind of packs
are at the end of their lives and will dirty heads -- at best --
and shouldn't be used.
Should I take the drive to the scrapyard immediately?
No.