I've made a few medium-complexity PCB's (and I really
mean, made, with icky chemicals, drills, etc). I
didn't tape them, I used a 17 year old (legit,
incredibly!) copy of Wintek's software. I like to
wire-wrap one-of's because it gives me a feeling of
satisfaction that I really built it (and didn't just
stuff parts in holes), and, to me anyway, it just
"looks" more handmade and unique. But if you designed
the PCB, you can get the satisfaction of designing the
board, and also the built-in capability of sharing or
selling your design easily to people who might not be
as committed or interested in the nasty details, but
just want something to work with a minimum of fuss. I
wire-wrapped a few 8008's and 8080's and sold them on
eBay, but it wasn't really worth my time, except when
I was unemployed. I'm thinking about doing PCB's and
selling 8080 and 6800 kits. Seriously!
--- Michael Holley <swtpc6800(a)attbi.com> wrote:
I used to do all of my stuff on wire-wrap. I am now
building classic
computer board that I want to show off and a PCB
looks so much better. I
have done a few circuit boards from ExpressPCB and
really like it.
Michael Holley
www.swtpc.com
----- Original Message -----
From: "Ethan Dicks" <erd_6502(a)yahoo.com>
To: <classiccmp(a)classiccmp.org>
Sent: Monday, April 01, 2002 2:35 PM
Subject: PCB vs perfboard construction economics
(was Re: "New" PDP-8)
--- Ben Franchuk <bfranchuk(a)jetnet.ab.ca>
wrote:
> ...The board will be about 8" x 7" and $175
canadian for two
> prototype boards. Wire wrap
sockets/wire/protoboard would cost me
$100...
While I can recommend a real PCB if the setup
costs and the per-sq-in
costs are not killing you (price an Omnibus or
Unibus-sized 4-layer board,
complete with gold fingers!), personally, my WW
overhead isn't terrible:
I rescued all the prototype hardware from my
former employer when they
went bust - I probably have three lifetimes worth
of WW sockets. When
I do a project, the only part I have to spend
money on is the wire.
My last project is a good case-study for expense
vs. time. I wanted to
replicate a scoreboard from a Dragon's
Lair/Space
Ace. I tried to find
one on ePay, but they only come up occasionally
(every couple of months).
I decided to build one. I started with a couple
of digital pictures,
a parts list and a schematic. Since the board
was
approx 6"x9", it
would have been somewhat expensive for a
commercially-made PCB. There
are still plenty of surplus units out there that
sell used for under $50
when they are available, so it would be cheaper
to
wait for a sale than
to have a professional PCB created unless the new
PCB added value somehow.
I had the blue perfboard (from when the
MicroCenter got rid of all of
their
prototyping hardware at 80% off list!), the wire
and the discrete
components. I had to purchase the LEDs ($0.65
each) and the driver chips
(a few bucks each). Total out-of-pocket expense
was <$25. I probably
pulled about $15-$20-worth of supplies out of my
parts bins.
Construction took place over several evenings,
watching the sci-fi
channel,
tacking down point-to-point connections
(didn't
have the vertical
clearance for socketing the LEDs). I'm
pleased
that it worked the first
time! - pictures at
http://penguincentral.com/retrocomputing/retrogaming/
under the
"LED Scoreboard" link. Mostly, it's
pictures of the glow of
the LEDs, but there's one out-of-focus,
flash-burned picture of the
perfboard and yellow wire in there (the Apple
QT150 has about a 24" min
focal distance without the strap-on lens).
The upshot was that if this were being done for
anyone but me personally,
it would have been an economic disaster. Nobody
would have paid me a
reasonable amount for that much work - it would
have been much cheaper
to go to an arcade service company and *buy* a
used scoreboard than spend
10+ hours wiring up a board. It would have been
much cheaper than that
to wait out the next wave of offerings on eBay
(which I accidentally did -
the project took so long to complete that I _did_
pick a real one up for
around $30, after I was 95% finished with my
replica. The good news is
that it made a nice functional benchmark to prove
that mine worked).
So I chose to trade my time for semi-instant
gratification. I would
have loved to have done a PCB, but I chose not to
spend the time with
layout tape and a blank board, and I chose not to
pay to register a
demo-ware layout package so I could make a
6"x9"
board. If I were to
make the new PDP-8 design that kicked off this
whole thread, I'm not
sure if I'd get professional boards
(~$200/set, in
small quantities,
according to the designer, for a couple of
4-layer
boards) or I'd
point-to-point it. In terms of $$$/hour, even
$200 for a board set
is cheap. In terms of a discretionary hobby,
$200
is a lot to divert
from other projects when I already _have_ a
working PDP-8. With that
kind of money, I could start trolling for a Qbus
SCSI controller!
Back to the initial topic, though, I'd love to get
a good buy on a dozen
or
so spools of kynar-coated wire. I'd prefer
an
assortment of colors, but
I'd take it in whatever I could get - yellow,
red,
white...
Anyone have a lead on any surplus places that have
it for a few bucks
a spool?
-ethan
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Greetings - send holiday greetings for
Easter, Passover
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Tax Center - online filing with TurboTax
http://http://taxes.yahoo.com/