"Zane H. Healy" <healyzh at aracnet.com> wrote:
Saw an
interesting discussion about CD-ROMs with MSCP SCSI (YES, a
CD-ROM ISO with XXDP would be truly awesome!) and this got me thinking
about my own UC07 controller - if I've understood correctly, this
controller does not support SCSI tape.
I don't really know anything about MSCP or the SCSI command set that CD
writers use - but could a CD-R(W) drive be used as a backup device?
I know it's bad style to do backups on CD-R, but bear with me :)
I don't see why not, but you'll have to write the software to control it.
I very much doubt it. Writing to a CD-R is not done the same way as
writing to a disk. And MSCP-SCSI controllers only do writes as to a disk.
CDs need to have lead-ins, lead-outs and whatnots in between.
(Underruns, anyone?)
You're also likely to find that it's very
picky about what it will work
with. At least with my Viking QDT and UDT controllers I *think* 512-byte
blocks are a requirement, and I know they won't work with all 512-byte block
CD-ROM drives.
My CMD controllers have been happy with every CD drive I've tossed at
them, but I admit it hasn't been that many different models, so I might
have been just lucky.
An easier sollution is to have the SCSI HD's in
removable trays, and Have a
modern Unix box with the same type SCSI tray. Plug the PDP-11 disk into the
Unix box, and use 'dd' to image the disk. The resulting image can even be
used under SIMH.
That would definitely be easier. If you wanted backups, you could then
burn that image to a CD on the Unix box.
Also, now that
I think about it, the perverse bugger that I am, could an
MSCP controller send an Audio CD Play/Next Track/etc. command to the
CD-ROM? Would be awesome to have a hifi controlled by the PDP-11. :)
No clue, but I rather doubt it.
Same problem. SCSI command to play around with audi CDs don't have any
corresponding stuff in MSCP, so there is no way to map that.
In short, MSCP can't do it. Don't matter what SCSI can. You are limited
to what MSCP can do, since it is a MSCP controller. What it talks at the
other end is pretty irrelevant.
Johnny
--
Johnny Billquist || "I'm on a bus
|| on a psychedelic trip
email: bqt at update.uu.se || Reading murder books
pdp is alive! || tryin' to stay hip" - B. Idol