On 10/12/2015 12:40 PM, Michael Thompson wrote:
Date: Sun, 11 Oct 2015 18:44:54 -0500
From: Jay Jaeger <cube1 at charter.net>
Subject: Re: PDP-12 Restoration at the RICM
Don't forget about the other more remote possibilities: cables,
backplane, bad wrap, supply voltages at the actual card(s) for the
mis-behaving channel, etc.
JRJ
We used different control and data cables for the TU55 and the TU56 drives
and observed the same track 3 bad behavior.
The backplane appears to be in good shape.
My scope had a little trouble looking at 10-15mV signals in differential
mode using the math functions, but we looked at the head signals going into
the track 3 amplifier, and they looked reasonable.
The power supply voltages at the cards are within spec. The track
amplifiers are supposed to be differential, so they should be fairly immune
to power supply noise. We plan to connect a lab supply to the backplane
near the track cards and adjust it slightly higher than the PDP-12 power
supply. That should clean up any 60Hz noise on the power. Maybe that will
help?
I had in mind the power to the cards in the PDP-12 itself, not the tape
drive(s). No local sense in those days, with considerable voltage drop
in the wiring. A bad wrap might add to that drop on the backplane itself.
We have swapped everything else between the tracks,
including the logic
analyzer probe, and the issue always stays with track 3. Maybe it is a
backplane wiring problem?
It is a possibility not to ignore. The reason I asked is that at Wis.
DOT we had an Amdahl 580 that was acting flaky - odd crashes without any
apparent connection. The machine was new, so Wis. DOT threatened to
send it back. Amdahl flew in something like 3 engineers from the
Sunnyvale plant, and they along with the 2 local FE's and one CE went
over the machine with magnifying glasses (literally), looking at
everything. They finally found one amazingly tiny coax wire (imagine a
coax cable about the diameter of a normal wire wrap wire) that had been
nicked/kinked by being pinched against a frame at some point - took them
almost all night to find it. They were happy but pretty "ripe" when I
came into work the next morning.
Based on that story, it occurred to me that corrosion on a wrap on the
PDP-12 backplane could be an issue.
The other possibility that occurs to me is a timing glitch - where two
signals change state at the same time and then are sampled too close to
that time, resulting in a signal being clocked into a latch the wrong
state. Those can be really hard to track down.
JRJ