I wonder if a really workable counterfeit could made
from
other than a different chip with new paint? Hopefully that won't
happen, but with this kind of money involved who knows.
There are discussions of this in CPU collector forums often. If the price is high enough,
it's well worth it (to thieves). China appears to be a significant source for
counterfeited chips, mainly "Engineering Samples," "Prototype" and
"Confidential" supplementary-marked chips. And I can imagine that somewhere
along the line, there were a whole bunch of ICs with exactly the same external appearance
as the 4004 that could be remarked. If the buyer doesn't functional check the chip or
open it up for die inspection, who'd know other than the thief who sold it?