On 19 Mar 2007 at 5:35, Dave Dunfield wrote:
Thanks for the response. So you have not seen this
before (single-
density working at 250kbps but not 300kbps)?
No, but it's not a practice I've followed much. Many, if not most,
of the FM-encoded 5.25" (exclusive of the 100 tpi format) formats use
48 tpi diskettes, so we've always recommended a 48 tpi drive to do
the work. And I don't think we have a single system here with your
SMC controller, although I think I still may have the datasheet
somewhere here.
It might have happened to us at some point with a customer, but we'd
have assumed that his was one of the many controllers that don't
handle FM at all, so our advice would have been the same--find
another mahine to try. The problem may have been masked entirely by
this.
When doing your testing, remember to separate the non-FM capable
controllers from the FM-capable-but-not-at 300K ones. Don Maslin and
I did start doing a fairly exhaustive survey of LSI single-function
diskette controllers to see what could handle FM and 128-byte
sectored MFM, but that was long ago, and we didn't include the very
new multi-I/O chips.
Maybe it's time for a new census, although I wonder--many systems
made since about 1995 won't support more than a single floppy anyway--
and I suspect that floppyless desktop PCs aren't that far off from
becoming the rule (many are still shipped with a 34-pin header on the
mobo just in case, but that won't stay around, I suspect).
Cheers,
Chuck