On Mon, Sep 23, 2013 at 12:40:17PM -0700, Chuck Guzis wrote:
[...]
Call it idle speculation, but what's the highest
speed a consumer-grade audio
modem can manage over VoIP, state of the art or otherwise? Has anyone tried
this?
In theory, the top speed of your modem. A VoIP ATA is after all doing exactly
the same job as the line card in your local telephone exchange, except without
miles of manky old copper in the way.
Practice, of course, is another matter. I know, because I tried it.
It was far too ambitious a project as the calling leg was GSM, and it also went
over a relatively slow ADSL line before being terminated on a modem that had
already had a very hard life. But hey, we like a good challenge :)
The outgoing GSM leg was 9600bps CSD, although the mobile telco converted that
into a V.34 call to my VoIP number for no obvious reason. V.34 wouldn't work at
all: it'd just squeal away negotiating lower speeds until giving up. I fiddled
with a whole load of S registers to disable modulation schemes that might be
latency-sensitive, and eventually got it to sort of hold a connection at
7200bps.
Had I *two* modems, I would have expected it to just work across my LAN.