On Mar 19, 2007, at 8:43 PM, Fred Cisin wrote:
Let's comply with the explicit and implicit terms
when somebody makes
something available.
THIS makes sense. If you put up a big pile of juicy stuff on an
FTP or web server and for some reason (bandwidth limitations or
billing, etc) you don't want someone to slurp the whole thing, SAY SO
SOMEWHERE, and also put into place rate- and connection-limiting
functionality to control people who won't control themselves and
comply with your wishes.
This whole issue is very much a double-edged sword. Every now and
then, I DO slurp down the entire contents of an online archive if I
run across something and think "wow it would suck if this just went
away". Most of the time this is with corporate sites, because lots
of things (PDF docs, drivers, etc) just disappear at the whim of
suits, and there's usually no other way to get ahold of it. I do
respect posted "please don't download this entire archive all at
once" requests when such requests are present.
In some instances, this is the right thing to do, for the greater
good. For example, if Don Maslin's (R.I.P.) boot disk archive had
been available online in some form (yes I recognize the technical
difficulties in doing so; I'm speaking hypothetically), I'd probably
have a copy of it today, as I recognize the rarity of the data. The
work he did was fantastic, and a great service to the community, but
it'd sure suck if that effort were to completely die with him.
-Dave
--
Dave McGuire
Port Charlotte, FL