Tony Duell wrote:
I could tell you many stories of times when I've
spent hours looking for
a fault only to find I've not plugged it into the mains, or there's no
fuse in the plug, or....
Well, as it turns out, I *was* partially brainless with this episode
(more below).
From memory,
there are 3 versions of the logic board used in the RL01.
The first oen is
RL01-only, the other 2 can be used either in an RL01 or
an RL02 with a jumper change. The last of those has many more testpoints
than the earlier one.
There are significant electronic differences between the first one and
the other 2. My RL01 printset only covers the first version, for the
others I look at the RL02 printset.
I have one of the older type, and the other three are of the new type.
But, turns out that it doesn't matter anymore, in terms of which
printset to use, since I think I have resolution to both drives'
problems (more below).
The pocket service guide (is that on Bitsavers?) is
probably the best
reference to tell the boards apart. I have that that booklet too, and can
tell you what to look for if you have problems.
Yes, I do have a copy of the pocket service guide, thanks to bitsavers.
Again, no longer required (more below), but very handy to have around.
I have already benefited from it.
I
wonder....could the heads, having been in the retracted position for
so long (years and years), be kind of 'glued' in place by dust/grime/dry
grease, thus no READY indication? Hmm...a question: is it advisable to
It's possible.
Okay, here's the good stuff you've been waiting for. Just to recap:
Drive 0 would not show READY. Trying to read from it anyway with RT11,
gave a 'drive not responding' kind of message (don't have the exact text
in front of me at the moment). And it put out a fair amount of
whining/rumbling when spun up.
Drive 1 would not show READY. (here's where I was brainless) I never
actually tried to read this drive, since I never saw READY (I was
already 'conditioned' by what I saw with Drive 0). This drive, too, put
out a significant whine as it spun.
Here's what I did:
I opened each drive up, and did two things to each: 1) With the upper
and lower head 'trays' propped apart, I manually exercised the r/w head
carriage, moving it back and forth a number of times, and 2) I put a
couple of drops of oil on the top of each motor's shaft, which was
easily reached with the service cover off.
Interestingly, Drive 0's head carriage *did indeed* have some fair
resistance to motion when I first tried to move it. As I exercised it a
few times it loosened up and moved pretty well after about a dozen full
travel cycles. I actually believe this was a problem. If the heads
couldn't budge, certainly the drive wouldn't come READY. I guess the
lubrication on the rails or the pull cable cylinder (or whatever it is
called) were somewhat gummed up. I didn't apply any additional
lubrication, since it loosened up pretty well after a few cycles, and I
didn't want to introduce into this area anything that wasn't according
to spec (whatever that may be).
Drive1's head carriage didn't show much resistance to motion when I
manually exercised it. This was useful information to me since it gave
me a sort of benchmark of comparison for what I experienced with Drive 0.
So, the bottom line:
Drive 0, having been reconnected to the 11/23, still didn't show READY,
but I *was* able to talk to it. I even went so far as to image a whole
disk cartridge to my PC without difficulty. Checking the READY
indicator bulb, I discovered the bulb was burned out. Duh! (I told you
I was partially brainless during this whole episode.) However, after
replacing the bulb with a new one (I have a supply for just this
purpose), I still don't get a READY light. More to look into, but the
drive now actually works!
Drive 1, also works just fine. (Uh, oh, more brainless-ness ahead...)
It, too, had a burned out bulb! And since I never actually tried to
read from this drive, after having no luck from Drive 0 (which had the
same symptoms at the time), I just assumed it was broken too. It was
probably only a bad bulb all along. A replacement bulb gave me a nice
READY indication. How stupid is that!?
The good news from going through this whole process is that I believe
the small amount of lubrication that I applied to both drives' motors
did the trick. Each drive is now quiet, at least as quiet as RL drives
usually are.
I *do* believe that the head carriage of Drive 0, was stuck, but it's
hard to prove it. It, the whole drive, works now (sans READY light),
and that's a whole lot better than a few days ago. I do think that a
bit of lubrication to the drives' motors was definitely useful.
I'll keep working on the Drive 0 READY indicator light. Probably some
broken or loose contact in the switch itself, or the front panel switch
assembly. I'll pull that and check everything.
Thanks for all of your input, Tony!
J.