On 04/04/11 12:55, Steven Hirsch wrote:
For components like a right-angle DE9 connector, the
top side of the
board is not accessible. Do you think using the hot-air handle for
preheat would do any good?
Well, it'd be worth a shot. The thing about a preheater is that it has a
much larger surface area -- so instead of heating a small patch of board
(which is what the hot-air gun is for) it'll bring the whole board (or a
large section of it) up to a given temperature.
The idea being that instead of having to bring every pin on the chip
from 25C to 250C to melt the solder, you have to heat
them from ~150C to
250C. Less energy required, faster time-to-melt, and as a result
less
damage to the PCB. Usually the solder joints will stay hot for a little
longer too -- meaning you get a few extra seconds to vacuum-pick the
part off of the board.
I think your
best bet would be a heated-vacuum tool. Basically a
solder-sucker mated to a soldering iron...
Alas, I have two of them. An older OK Industries tool and a new
BlackJack Solderwerks thingie from Circuit Specialists. Neither of them
is worth a crap from my experience.
Well, that ties in with my experience with the Aoyue one (basically a
clone of one of the Hakko workstation-type vacuum solder suckers). I
would have thought the OKI one would have been pretty decent though...
weren't they Metcal at one point?
* Melt some
fresh solder into the joint. Rosin flux paste or gel
(usually used for SMD soldering) is also worth a try.
I do that as a matter of course - it does help a lot.
I suspect the reason that trick works is the flux -- you add extra flux,
which helps to remove oxidised solder. The bit of extra solder improves
the thermal coupling between soldering iron tip and joint.
* 24swg tinned
copper wire is GREAT for clearing solder out of through
holes without damaging the plating. Enamelled copper might work too.
This would be _after_ the component is removed, correct? If not, would
you mind elaborating a bit?
Yes -- exactly right. You cut the pins off with flush-cutters -- these
are the very small wire-nippers that you usually use to cut component
pins flush to a solder joint, not the massive (by comparison)
side-cutters usually used for cutting wire and cable.
Cut the pins and remove as much of the connector frame as possible. I
usually use a Dremel and a selection of cutting/grinding bits to go most
of the way through, then finish off with hand tools -- needle files and
maybe a junior hacksaw blade. Desolder the pins and pull them out, the
holes will be filled with solder.
Put some flux on the joint, and a drop of solder on your iron tip. Apply
to the joint and melt in some fresh solder until you get a convex bubble
on both sides. Use desolder wick to remove this -- sometimes you can
push a little bit of the wick into the hole, which helps A LOT when
wicking solder out of holes.
If the hole won't clear after two or three tries at this, remove all the
solder you can, then heat a piece of tinned copper wire alongside the
joint, like this:
wire
| ## soldering iron tip
| ##
|##
=============== board
Push the wire through the hole while heating it. Again: fresh solder and
flux are VERY useful. If it won't go through from one side, try the
other side. When the wire goes through, start moving it up and down, and
remove the soldering iron. The motion prevents the solder from sticking
to the wire.
You should now have a clean (or close enough) hole which you can push a
new part lead through (and solder it).
I picked up a quantity of carbide-tipped PCB drills
for just such a
purpose. Sort of a last resort, I'll grant you.
I've got a box full of the things... only problem with carbide bits is
that they break if you look at them funny.
Is the Kapton tape available from electronic
suppliers? I'll take a look
at the DigiKey catalog forthwith.
Any decent supplier should have it. Farnell stock the 3M stuff, but it's
unbelievably expensive (?30 a roll). Their own-brand version
("Multicomp") is about a third of the price. I honestly can't remember
if you get 10m or 25m on a roll... but it lasts ages. Just don't let the
kids near it!
Either the 12.7mm (1/2in) or 18mm wide tape is fine for most things. The
thinner stuff (1/4in) is better if you're going to be taping down wires
and nothing else...
--
Phil.
classiccmp at philpem.me.uk
http://www.philpem.me.uk/