On 01/12/05, Cini, Richard <Richard.Cini at wachovia.com> wrote:
All:
I'm thinking of ditching Windows totally on my desktop at home
as I build my next upgraded x86-bsed PC. So, I wanted to take a poll of the
group for a recommendation on which Linux distro to use. I downloaded Fedora
Core, Slackware, FreeBSD, Unbuntu and Linspire.
Any thoughts from the group?
Time for my usual 5min instant distro summary.
I'm going to make some assumptions:
- you want a GUI desktop machine
- you want some basic productivity apps & Internet clients
- you have a reasonably modern x86 PC that would run W2K or XP happily
You have some choices to make.
Do you mind paying for it?
Do you want to play around, fiddle, try different things out, or do
you want it to just work so you can get on with using your computer?
If you don't mind paying, then:
- for a do-everything loads-of-toys distro, try Mandriva or SuSE. Both
are very complete, easy GUI-based distros with good admin tools.
- for a simple Windows-replacement, try Xandros.
If you don't want to pay, or are happy to put up with a slightly
limited free eval version, then:
- for the do-everything types, again, Mandriva or SuSE
- for a simple quick clean GUI desktop, try Ubuntu. Small, fast, does
the job. Based on Debian so you can hack around with it if you so
choose, changing desktop environments, window managers, whatever you
like.
That covers it. Other contenders:
- for all-in-one GUI solutions, there's also Mepis, which some people
really rate.
- if you don't mind running something that is essentially in eternal
beta-test and never stabilizes, Fedora Core is allegedly all right.
Only Red Hat fans tend to like it.
If you don't want a GUI desktop, but want to assemble your own OS from
the pieces, then:
- Slackware is the oldest currently-maintained distro. Nice simple
BSD-style init, fairly minimal and thus fast, but setup and package
management are a bit paleolithic. The package management is being
modernised, though, but is still based around tarballs. If you don't
know what a tarball is, you don't want Slackware.
- Debian is arguably the One True Linux. Old, stable, reliable, the
best package management around, massive library of software. You
choose the edition: stable version (mission-critical boxes: changes
very slowly, essential bugfixes only), unstable or testing (constantly
shifting, where new stuff is tried out.) Needs configuring and
building entirely by hand - expect to write lots of config files.
Learning curve like the north face of the Eiger.
- Gentoo. For the sort of person who glues a bodykit onto a small
boring hatchback. Compile everything from scratch so you have the
exact compiler optimisations for your individual machine. Can be very
fast as a result. Requires considerable knowledge to get working.
Anything else is, frankly, marginal, or costs thousands and is
intended for corporate servers.
Avoid Linspire: pretty, easy, but no security & no bundled apps;
defaults to running as 'root' at all times, all apps & extras cost
money.
--
Liam Proven ?
http://livejournal.com/userinfo.bml?user=lproven
AOL/AIM/iChat: liamproven at
aol.com ? MSN/Messenger: lproven at
hotmail.com
Yahoo: liamproven at yahoo.co.uk ? Skype: liamproven ? ICQ: 73187508
Gmail/Google Talk/Orkut: lproven at
gmail.com