On Mon, 9 Feb 2009, Mr Ian Primus wrote:
But, we're drifting off-topic again. The question
is really "Can a
hobbyist, with modern technology, build a device to write new alignmnent
disks?". I definitely think so. Such a device would definitely be a mix
of new and old parts. I mean, why reinvent the disk drive? The basic
disk motor, heads, frame, etc. should be fine.
The only thing I think that could use an upgrade would be the
positioner. Voice coil positioning isn't really what we want here. The
only thing we care about is precision, not speed. A stepper would work,
just maybe one that's more precise than the one in the drive - or
perhaps one that's gear reduced. A leadscrew based drive might be a good
candidate, with some kind of precision servo on it. It doesn't matter
how fast it is, just as long as it's accurate. Who cares if it takes ten
minutes to write an alignment disk?
~30 years ago, I took an SA400, added an additional tiny pointer and made
labelled calibration marks alongside the spiral groove. It was CERTAINLY
useless for alignment, but it worked GREAT for introducing an OS class to
the basics of what a drive did. "watch as it goes to track 0 to read the
boot sector." "Notice the return to the directory track after it writes
the data." I had a few students who couldn't understand the fundamental
problems with SMARTDRV, including re-arranged write sequence, until I went
through the process a few times, and then said, "What happens if the power
goes away NOW?"
The drive is long gone, but I occsaionally [not recently] stumble across
some of my extra SA400 groove disks.
--
Grumpy Ol' Fred cisin at
xenosoft.com