On Mon, Oct 8, 2012 at 11:56 AM, Toby Thain <toby at telegraphics.com.au> wrote:
RAID !=
backup != offsite backup!
I consider RAID as an availability measure - but how many installations have
you seen that have spare disks on-hand and procedures to monitor and replace
them? (I am sure the serious ones do. Elsewhere, every cowboy sysadmin
configures RAID on day 1... but where are the disks? :)
The IceCube datacenter at Pole keeps dozens of spare disks on hand for
replacements, but there, you can't just phone someone up in June and
get a disk shipped in overnight... well... it'll be there half-past
sunrise, but that means "November" in this case.
One advantage of a remote site is that you *know* you can't get parts
in when you want them so you have to plan in advance and maintain a
spares pile. No other place I've worked kept spare hardware around
like that - when it dies, call it in and they send one (and you hope
that a second disk doesn't die before the first arrives). Had that
happen exactly once - disk 1 dies, call for replacement, 5 hours
later, disk 2 dies, replace 2 disks in moments then spend days
rebuilding the array from what backups there are.
-ethan