On 10/6/2011 2:48 PM, Tony Duell wrote:
Why would anybody replace a device containing 4 simple
components
(transformer, fuse, and 2 diodes) with something containg many more
components (the PC PSU)???
Although it may offend you in principle, "obsolete" PCs show up in the
gutter around here, but TRS80 parts cost money.
You mean there really are classic computer people who don't have boxes of
assorted fuses, diodes, etc? Amazing...
-tony
Please, enough of the self-righteousness that always seems to highlight
your purist tendencies, including the ability to construct transistors
from raw materials and simple hand tools. We know where you stand already.
Sorry, my last comment was intended to be sarcastic, it didn't come
across that way I guess.
However, if we go back to the original problem of reparing or replacing
a TRS-80 Model 1 power brick :
The TRS-80 has linear voltag regulators on the CPU board (I have the
schematics here), the inputs on the DIN connector are therefore higher
voltages than the required +5V, -5V and +12V.
You cna't, therefore, conenct some of the wires from a normal PC power
supply (be it a PC, PC/AT, or ATX supply) to a 5 pin DIN plug and use it
to power an unmodified TRS-80 Model 1. You have at least 2 options if you
want to use one. Either modify the PC power supply to give out highet
voltages, and feed those into an unmodified Model 1 (but the PC power
supply is likely to be undocumented...) or modify the model 1 by
bypassing the regulators so that it taks in +/-5V and +12V (but then
having a machine that will be ruined if you conenc tthe original PSU to
it, and hoping that the rails come up in the right order to avoid damage
to the DRAMs).
Both strike me as quite abit of work, and require some electronics
knowledge. The oriignal power brick cotnisn 4 components, one of which
(the transformer) is not likely to have failed. They can all be tested
using simple equipment (multimeter and a series light bulb). It stikes me
that repairing the origianl brick is less work, and requires less
electronic knowledge than using a PC power supply in this case.
You comment would be somewhat more jsutified is I was commenting on
repairing a complex regulated-output PSU .vs. replacing it with a PC
supply. In that case ofteh the PS supply gives the right votlages, it's
just a connector change. I don't like doing it becase, yes, I am a purist
and I regurd the PSU as being part of the original design of the machine.
But I can accept in thsi case that wiring a handful of wires to a
connector is easier than doing battler with an SMPSU that decides to blow
components off the board.
-tony