----- Original Message -----
Date: Sun, 16 Jun 2013 16:54:53 -0500 (CDT)
From: Tothwolf <tothwolf at concentric.net>
> On Sun, 16 Jun 2013, MikeS wrote:
...
It just seems
that seven or eight people have 'taken over' the list as a
forum for their often lengthy and OT opinions and arguments, while I see
familiar people with much to contribute leaving and appearing on other
lists instead and citing the above 'noise' as the reason (not to mention
the folks still here begging them to keep it down and on topic).
A shame IMO.
Oh no you don't.
I've been here long enough to have witnessed first hand that no matter
-what- computer-related topic comes up, /someone/ on the list is going to
take offense to the topic under discussion.
----- Reply: -----
I don't know where you get the idea that I (and Josh) are *offended* by
anything; the only person who seems to be offended is Dave...
Being called a moron and a jerk and being told that I suck because I don't
see anything necessarily wrong with scrapping a system for parts could
certainly be considered rude and offensive, but that really just reflects on
the name-callers' character and maturity.
There's no question that pretty well everyone on this list has things to
contribute, including and sometimes especially Dave and the above-mentioned
high posters; what I (and, I think, Josh) are suggesting is that the noise
level gets pretty high sometimes and that perhaps the relatively few people
creating most of the noise might take a moment to think whether that
opinion, argument, whatever, is really worth the bandwidth and time to post,
not to mention the replies that it will provoke.
But predictably, it's just like asking the neighbours to please keep the
noise down a bit; the usual reply is a hostile "go f$%k yourself" and the
noise gets cranked up even more.
I still think that it's a shame when the noise drives valuable people to
other, friendlier, lists with higher S/N ratios; they don't seem to be
missed by anyone else here and I'm on those lists as well, so no problem I
guess.
IMO, other than for HP and DEC issues CCtalk is becoming less and less
relevant to many members of the community, but perhaps that's as it should
be...
So, no, I'm not offended; I'm also subscribed to CCtech so I can choose to
just read the 'edited' version, or even unsubscribe altogether if I do get
too annoyed or even "offended."
Back to our regular programming...
m