On Wed, 25 Jul 2012, Al Kossow wrote:
On 7/24/12 8:55 PM, Tothwolf wrote:
Too bad he didn't use the right solder.
"No-Clean" lead-free solder
didn't exist back then.
There are SO many wrong things about this copy. Machine-tooled sockets,
modern monolythic ceramic caps. I'm surprised he bothered with carbon
comp resistors.
On the other hand, it will probably be much more reliable than the
original, just by using decent sockets.
I'm not so sure...
With those sockets, you have gold contacts against tin plated IC leads.
This can cause all sorts of problems where the gold isn't hard enough to
break through the tin oxide. New tin oxide will also begin to transfer to
the surface of the gold contacts. We saw this a lot back with 30-pin and
72-pin SIMMs when people would put modules with gold-plated contacts in
sockets with tin contacts.
Then there are those carbon comp resistors... We have no way of knowing
the vintage and storage history of those resistors. Carbon comp resistors
in general really, really don't like humidity and will drift in value over
time as humidity begins to affect the carbon. This is why modern metal
film resistors are much more reliable then carbon comps in general purpose
applications. Hopefully he happened to use old stock AB resistors since
their carbon comp resistors were somewhat better sealed and tended to age
/much/ better.