"Ethan Dicks" <ethan.dicks at gmail.com> wrote:
I guess another way to phrase this might be, does
anyone on the list
know of a source of extremely inexpensive piles of DLT IV or SDLT
tapes - either density media quickly adds up to more than the present
cost of drives, so in the end, it's the weight of the tapes that's the
limiting factor.
For data backup, it's a false economy to compare the cost of the
backup media to the cost of other backup media or to the cost
of gas or to the cost of tea in China.
The true comparison is the cost of making a backup vs the cost of
not making a backup.
For more than a decade folks have argued about the cost of backup media
vs another backup media, and ignored the cost vs value of doing
the backup at all. The cost of the media has been in the noise
compared to the effort involved for a long long time, at least for
those of us in the West. (Maybe things are different in former
Eastern Block countries or subsaharan Africa, not that living at
the South Pole might distort any of our senses of economics!)
For almost any application, the convenience vs inconvenience of the
backup is going to drive any consideration more than the cost of the
media. DLT does have a very good advantage over others in convenience
in that there is a good (although not perfect) history of drives
being backwards compatible over ridiculously long time spans.
There are OTHER factors - I made backups onto 9-tracks into the late
90's mostly as a justification for keeping dozens of drives around, not
so much because it was the best or right way! If you want to pick
up the tapes as a way of justifying keeping the DLT drive around,
that's great: well into the late 90's I was still stockpiling vast
quantities of Blackwatch tape (I mean, thousands of tape in a haul)
just as part of my spinning tape reel obsession :-). But once the other
non-economic factors come in, you have to acknowledge that you are
no longer making decisions based solely on some hypothetical economic
factor and abandon the economic comparisons.
Tim.