Roy J. Tellason wrote:
On Saturday 31 May 2008 11:30, Patrick Finnegan
wrote:
> On Friday 30 May 2008, Tony Duell wrote:
>>>> After working on a SMPSU (or any power supply for that matter,
>>>> but especially a switcher), I usually power it up to test
>>>> throught a light-bulb. [...] Has saved me from "secondary
>>>> catastrophic failures" on more than one occation.
>>> And I've heard people talk about banning incandescent bulbs
>>> entirely.
>> Indeed...
> I don't see what the problem is. There are much more efficient methods
> of lighting, than the one that Edison worked a lot on over 100 years
> ago.
Incandescents make great dummy loads for transmitters. CFL's decidedly
do not. etc...
Another problem with CFL's is that they are very risky in explosive
and combustible atmospheres than incandescents. There are sealed light
fixtures for incandescents but they are not approved for use with
CFL's. Some CFL's, perhaps all, will not fit in the incandescent
fixtures. CFL's may also be too hot for such sealed fixtures.
And another problem is that CFL's cannot tolerate shock & vibration
anywhere near to the degree that incandescents can. There are
fluorescents specifially designed for vibration but they are expensive
as hell and they are not CFL's. In a recent 1.0 quake on an unknown
fault, all the CFL's broke in an office building less than 1/2 mile
from the fault.
And yet another problem is that CFL's cannot tolerate the high
temperature environments that incandescents can. There are
fluorescents specifically designed for this, too, but they also are
very expensive.
Oh, I think this might be a problem too: The color and color
temperature of CFL's is not consistent even within lots and there is
frequently UV leakage, especially among the imports (yeah, like
Chinese imports). For some imaging apps, this is intolerable. Requires
the lamps be replaced with very expensive lighting systems like gas
discharge lighting. Or requires time-wasting constant color
adjustments, etc, adn. Most incandescents used in imaging have known
colors and color temperatures and any changes over the bulb's lifetime
are predictable.
Ever put a CFL on a microscope, replacing the halogen lamp? Doesn't
work very well. It's impossible to get a good parallel light onto the
work. This is for inline lighting, with the lighting done through the
optical path, not the external illuminators.
==
jd