4) The bit I get flaemd for soemtimes. Connect a
summy load to the
PSU (car bulbs -- 6V and 12V -- are useful for this) and run the
power supply on its onw. Check the output voltages, Check for
excessinve ripple if you have a 'scope.
Now I'm curious. Why would anyone flame you for doing, or suggesting,
that? (I don't recall seeing such flamage on the list; perhaps I
missed it, or forgot....)
There are some who just feel it's fun to flame, I guess (or at least
that's the only exxplanation I can find...). But htere have been more
serious reasons for not doing it :
It takes time (but not half as much time as rebuidlign a machine where
the PSU has gone crazy!), you have to get some parts (the dummy load
bulbs nd a multimeter, at least), and there's the possibility of damaging
the machine by taking it apart (all I can say to that is that I've
dismantled a couple of hundred classic computers in my time, and haven't
don't permeanent damage to any of them).
Probably most fo the time it _is_ safe to just power up and see what
happens, just as mosto f the itme you don't need dual-circuit brakes in a
car, you don't need seat belts, you don't need a tension band or an
implopsion screeen on a CRT, etc. It's the other times that you're glad
of them.
And yes I have had PSUs that were faulty. Most recently was one of the
cable PSUs in an HP11305 disk cotnroller, the 723 regualtor was defective
and the output was sittign at about 12V. I don;t know what would have
happened if tyhe crowbar had been connected (it's on a separate PCB,
along with some of the logic), and I certainly wasn't goign to find out.
Most likely it would have just been another burnt resisotr and a blown
mains fuse. But it could have been worse...
(One note. I doubt tony needs to be told this, for two different
reasons, but it might not have occurred to others. If you don't have a
THe 2 reasons being (a) I haev a 'scope and (b) I know the trick anyway?
'scope handy, you can often get a decent idea of
the amount of ripple
present by using an AC voltmeter in series with a moderately large
capaci-- um, condenser, for DC isolation. If your meter is known to
Sure, I do that soemtimes, it's quite handy if you are working on a large
machien and can't eaily get the 'scope to it.
What you need is that the impedance of the capacitor at the mains
frequency is small compared ot the input resistnace of the meter. Most
DMMs are 10M Ohms (but soem are less o nthe AC ranges -- check the
manual). Aanlogue meters are considerably lower.
A 1uF capacitor should be fine for most cases. Even if you cna't get an
accrate measure of the ripply, you cna at least see if it's higher than
you might expect.
One advantage the 'scope has though, is that it lets yo see the ripple
frequency. On linear PSUs, ripple at twice the mains frequency is likely
to be dried-up smoothing capacitors (jsut about all PSUs have full-wave
rectifiers). Ripple at the mains frequency often means a defective diode
in the rectifier.
For SMPUSs, ripple at twice mains frequency leads you to the smoothing
capcitors o nthe mians side. Ripplye at the stiching frequency (10's of
kHz), particulalt sharp spikes, leads you to the output capacitors.
-tony