On 30 Jan 2009 at 16:13, Brent Hilpert wrote:
I believe in that discussion he's referring to
objects in their pure form: when
he says SMPS he means just the DC-to-DC converter; not what we colloquially
refer to as a SMPS, which is really a conventional AC-DC converter (rectifier &
filter) followed by a switch-mode DC-DC converter.
As I would understand it, the problem with adding the EMI filter to the front
of the SM DC-DC converter is that the converter actually draws current from the
DC source at a frequency corresponding to the switch-mode frequency, so the
current through an input EMI filter is nothing like DC, and you can get AC
interaction between the filter and the DC-DC converter. The EMI filter becomes
the resonant circuit, and negative resistance characteristics appearing at the
the input of the DC-DC converter turn the combination into an oscillator.
Thanks for the elaboration! I hadn't read the whole thing yet, but
was mildly surprised at the lede. Your explanation makes sense.
Cheers,
Chuck