On 5/29/07, Gordon JC Pearce <gordon at gjcp.net> wrote:
I guarantee you that you won't tell the difference
between a frame from
a good digital SLR, and a scanned frame from slide film in an equivalent
SLR.
What's your cutoff for a "good digital SLR"? I have an Olympus E-10.
It was top-of-the-line over 5 years ago - fixed lens with true
9mm-36mm focal length ("1/4 sized CCD", so 36mm-144mm equivalent),
62mm diameter (large compared to most digital cameras, so at f/2 -
f/2.4, its lens is a bit faster than you commonly see), but being as
old as it is, "only" 4 megapixel. When it was new, this camera
retailed around $1800-$2000. I picked it up in 2003 for $650, when it
was no longer at the top of the pack. A friend of mine just got one
from eBay last week for $150.
My best resolution with this camera is on the order of 2.5K x 1.5K
pixels. That's still quite a bit less than film. For webbish stuff,
though, plenty of resolution. I still have a few 35mm cameras, but
with the cost of film and processing, I don't do as much with it as I
used to (less than a dozen rolls of slide film per year). I do,
however, use it when I want to take stunning pictures of Antarctic
scenery. Between noisy pixels and contrast differences between ASA 50
slide film and a CCD, the visual impact of real film is amazing. For
indoor shots of computer bits under controllable lighting conditions
with a target image size of 800x600 or less, there's not much
difference in perceived quality.
If by "good digital SLR", you mean something in the 8-10MP range, with
removable lenses that one can tailor to the application at hand (by
spending enough $$$), then I would say that they are approaching SLR
resolution (numbers I've heard from a Hollywood cameraman are that
35mm movie film is considered to have "4000 lines of resolution" for
the purposes of generating special effects and certain kinds of image
subtleties), but not quite there.
$5000 worth of digital camera (body and lenses) can compete with a
$100 used SLR. $1000 worth of digital camera can't in many
circumstances.
-ethan