>>>> Of course. Anything done with chips
can also be done with
discrete
>>>> components.
>>> a "pentium" laptop ?
>
> On Sun, 14 Oct 2012, Tothwolf wrote:
>> Since nobody said how big the board could be... Multiple full AT
>> sized boards in a backplane for a luggable Pentium "laptop"? :)
>
A Pentium 166 MMX chip, which was a common chip with mobility features
used in some early Pentium-based laptops uses roughly 4.5M transistors.
A little math (and this is all approximations and done conservatively)
shows what might result.
Such a CPU, using small-outline surface mount leadless transistors on
12x9 circuit boards with relatively tight design rules and multi-layer
boards, would take something like 32 boards just for the transistors.
Add in the overhead of other discrete components and you are looking at
something like 81 boards (assuming roughly 2.5 discrete components per
transistor). Not allowing any room for chassis, backplane, board
spacing (for cooling), cooling, and interconnect, the CPU alone would a
cube roughly 21 inches on a side. Add in overhead for the stuff listed,
you'd probably be looking at a cube 2 feet on each side. The CPU by
itself could probably be packed into some kind of backpack, but it'd be
heavy.
That's just for the CPU.
Then you'd need RAM, ROM, IDE storage interface, keyboard interface,
mouse interface, serial, parallel, floppy disk, a video subsystem, and
LCD panel. Just the electronics for all of these things, assuming the
use of ICs of the time rather than trying to make them all using
discrete components, and it's my guess that the result would be too
large and too heavy to carry...not even considering what it'd take to
power the beast.
If you tried to do everything with discrete components(except the hard
disk and LCD display) -- well...it'd be more like something (a pure
guess) like 12 or so 7-foot 19" datacenter racks full of boards, and the
interconnect would be a real nightmare. Power distribution and cooling
would be "interesting". Hardly laptop, much less "luggable".