--- On Mon, 4/20/09, Eric J Korpela <korpela at ssl.berkeley.edu> wrote:
Some of the smoke came out of my Osborne 1 this
weekend. It
doesn't
appear to have been fatal, as it was still functioning when
I cut the
power. I'm giving the CRT some time to fully discharge
before I open
it up, probably next weekend. It was probably a failing
capacitor,
although it didn't explode, it merely got really warm
over a period of
hours. But since there are some similar machines that I
haven't
recently used, this question came to mind.
Does the Osborne have a tantalum capacitor in it? Those tend to blow without warning, for
no good reason. When they go, you get lots of magic smoke and burning - but your device
tends to stay working. Filter caps can go with smoke too - and depending on the deivce, it
might keep going, or fail.
I think people get really way over-concerned about electrolytics. These devices are old...
but not that old. Slow powerup would be a good idea for seriously old stuff (pre-50's,
mainly), primarily just to check for shorts. I use a series light bulb for that. But if
the cap is bad enough that it's going to exlplode on powerup, it isn't going to
reform to a useable state.
This is one of those often discussed "holy war" topics, and comes up once a year
or so. My mindset has always been to cross my fingers and plug it in, especially for
common, documented things like an Osborne or a TRS-80. If a capacitor blows up, then you
know that it's bad, and should be replaced - and it's marked clearly with a
smoking hole. For rarer things, I try to go in stages, testing the power supply first with
a dummy load to ensure that it's good before going on.
But the fact of the matter is, when you're working with old stuff, you are going to be
replacing a fair number of electrolytic capacitors. They just don't last. And the
typical failure mode has them simply operating poorly - not exploding.
A tradition at VCF East is the releasing of the magic smoke (Andy is usually on top of
this one), and while spactacular, all affected devices have since been repaired. (Canon
Cat, Apple IIe, Kaypro, Apple ProFile...)
-Ian