7 Jan
2022
7 Jan
'22
8:02 a.m.
On 1/6/2022 7:03 PM, W2HX via cctalk wrote:
My 2c. I am not familiar with a "whine" but
certainly a "hum." Sometimes if a power supply has seen a lot of heavy load over
its lifetime, the heat generated can begin to do things to the transformer. And once that
heat has done its "thing" to the transformer, it stays that way. And no
replacing external components will change the hum. However, there are some transformers
with bolts and nuts that hold the laminations together. Sometimes they can be tightened to
reduce the hum. I don?t know this PS specifically and whether it falls into this category
or not.
I don?t know if what you are hearing is transformer hum, but if it is, you may just have
to live with it.
73 Eugene W2HX
Subscribe to my Youtube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/w2hx-channel/videos
This does not fall "into this category". This is typically high
frequency (in excess of 10KHz) whine, not 60 cycle, 120 cycle or even
400 cycle "hum".
My experience with many PDP-11 machines going back to the mid 1970s, and
those in my collection, is that this whine from the *switching* power
supplies is very common. For some people, it may be above the frequency
that they can hear. For me it is not (I could also hear burglar alarms
in excess of 20KHz back in the day, though I doubt I could now, at age 70.)
My *guess* is that it comes from the inductors in the switching circuit,
and is *mechanical*, induced by the switching waveform, which in turn is
dependent upon load. If I had one that was really bad, I'd be tempted
to put on a glove for insulation and hold those to see if the mechanical
pressure made any difference.
JRJ