Hi Tony,
Tony Duell wrote:
For the machines I mentioned, the PDP8s, PDP11s,
and Philips P800s have a
hardware front panel that works even without any boot disks. You can
toggle in short programs and run them -- certainly programs to cause
As soon as you do that, you're running software - even if your intention
of interacting with it is only to cause output on a scope, even if it's
one opcode at a time. :-)
Technically, that is of course correct. But the original thread was
clearly about things like operating syustems, applications, languages, etc.
Completely different from just powering up and
admiring it (or using it
as a space heater, or listening to the fans.)
Assming the CPU is not defective, and it's not being held in a reset or
halt state, then it's executing instructions. Maybe just from random
noise on the data bus, bnt it'll take that set of 1's and 0's as
instructions. So a powered-up machines is probagly running some kind of
'software'.
The former is
obviously more
interesting (as I said, I do try to get boot disks for my classics), but
the latter is a lot better than nothing.
In the same way, running an emulator is a lot better than nothing, if
you don't have the actual machine. :-)
No arguemtn with that.
Oe perhaps one little one... I'd rather spend my time working on the
hardware of a machine I do own (and I am not short of things to do...)
than running an emulator for a machine that I don't.
You may feel differently. Fine. I'm not going to stop you.
-tony