At 06:25 PM 9/22/2014, Tothwolf wrote:
I think at one point designers were needlessly using
more tantalums because they seemed different, or thought of them as an
"improved" replacement for aluminum electrolytics.
I have seen tantalum electrolytics used on densely packed boards where the aluminium
electrolytics of the time would have taken up much more space (the best quality aluminum
electrolytics today are more compact than they were a few decades ago). I have an example
in the shop at the moment - a Harris RT-1446 HF military transceiver ca. 1980 (the
civilian version was the RF-350K). Unfortunately there seems to have been a problem with
the 10 uF 25 V tantalum electrolytics used to bypass the +15/-15 rails where the enter
each board. Many of them have failed in many transceivers, so many in fact that when I get
one of those transceivers into the shop for repair one of the first things that I do is to
shotgun all of those rail bypass caps.
Dale H. Cook, Roanoke/Lynchburg, VA
Osborne 1 / Kaypro 4-84 / Kaypro 1 / Amstrad PPC-640
http://plymouthcolony.net/starcity/radios/index.html