----- Original Message -----
From: <mailman at trailing-edge.com>
To: <cctalk at classiccmp.org>
Sent: Friday, July 03, 2009 10:32 AM
Subject: Write-only backup media and big archives
Not really a mechanical or procedural thing, but a
little more
philosophical as I think about data storage not just at home
for classic computing, but at work:
In the 90's the CD-R and soon after the DVD-R looked pretty ideal
for making "write only" backups of what was then considered large
amounts of data. While not archival in the centuries sense, it
seemed a pretty safe bet that readers would be readily available for
the next 10 or 20 years and I think this bet has turned out well.
I was willing to spend an afternoon buring a dozen or two CD-R's
because they felt "real".
But today, a "large amount of data" is not a few gigabytes, but
terabytes. Tape libraries with these sorts of capacities do
exist but aren't available at the corner store
and I have a nagging mistrust of tapes that causes me to refer
to them as "write only memory". (I never really ever trusted anything
denser than 1600BPI 9-track!). Burning 2000 CD-R's or even 500 DVD-R's
doesn't seem like a reasonable or useful task to backup a terabyte
hard drive (which today is a fraction the price of the 9 Gig drives of the
mid-90's that was "big storage".)
At the same time, the ubiquitous and available-at-the-corner-store
terabyte-sized USB drives don't feel awfully reliable either. They
are way more convenient and cheap though, and that's my prefered
backup media today.
I think I'm falling into the trap of confusing the price of storage
with the value of the information recorded onto the storage. It's
ironic that as disk space has become cheaper and cheaper, we regard
the contents as less worthy of the effort of backup onto reliable
media.
OK, philosophy mode off. The NTSB is gonna be asking me for a few
gigabytes of data next week and that seems easy compared to the
terabytes at home.
You left out MO media, which was popular before CDR/DVDR came out and was
meant to last a while (and DVD-RAM which was late to the game).
How much of the home users HD is filled with their original content and how
much is just downloaded material they can download again if they even
noticed it was gone? Businesses seem to have some kind of backup/archive
proceedure but few home users do anything outside of just dumping it to
another HD.