At 06:07 PM 11/15/04 -0800, you wrote:
Tony Duell wrote of crowbar protection circuits thus:
I'd rather not trust a protection device if I
don't have to. Sure I like
crowbar circuits, and they have saved my chips a few times, but I don't
like to depend on them.
Ah, twice in one week I get to expose my wanton ignorance. :) What
typically makes up a crowbar circuit? How are they triggered? If I'm
understanding this correctly, a crowbar quickly kills the PSU and then
drains power from the system rapidly and nondestructively... but how it
accomplishes this, or knows it _should_, I don't yet understand.
A crowbar is a very simple yet effective circuit to prevent PSUs from outputing
excessive voltage. It's nothing more than a SCR (Silicon Controlled Rectifier) across
the PSU output and a zener diode from the gate of the SCR to ground (and a small resistor
to supply a small amount of current to the gate-zener junction). The zener sets the trip
voltage of the SCR. The resistor-zener combination forms a small constant voltage source
that is applied to the SCR gate. Anytime the PSU output exceeds the zener voltage (plus
the gate voltage of the SCR) the SCR fires and becomes a dead short (minus a fraction of a
volt due to the SCR PN junction) and the PSU output is shorted out. Once the SCR fires it
says on regardless of the trigger voltage. The only way to remove the short is to turn off
power to the PSU and let it discharge and then reapply power. As you might have guessed
these circuits are very fast since they're so simple and they're located right on
the PSU output. The FAST response and nearly dead short account for the name
"crowbar". It has the effect similar to that of throwing a metal crowbar right
across the PSU output.
And yes the PSU had better be able to handle the almost dead short or have a fuse or
circuit breaker in it or something is going to give!
Joe
O'course, one could accomplish this with an actual crowbar applied
across the PSU output... but I suspect this would not be described as
"nondestructive". :)
-O.-