Ethan Dicks schrieb:
On Tue, Jun 9, 2009 at 5:38 PM, Allison<ajp166 at
bellatlantic.net> wrote:
What is different about the metal can and the plastic case part? I
have a few of each, and have so-far interchanged them in circuits
where performance isn't an issue (i.e., where a 2N3904 would work
fine, too). Obviously 2N2222s aren't expensive, but I'd like to know
why I should set aside the metal-cased ones for repairing specific
items.
Older transistors were generally put into a metal, and sometimes into a
ceramic package, case
for manufacturing reasons and better thermal distribution. Even earlier
transistor cases were
made of glass, painted black (you can make good photo transistors from
old OCxxx devices
when scratching the black paint away).
Plastic packages came up around late 60s when industry found materials
with both good insulation
and good thermal conduction. Nowadays, putting a semiconductor chip into
a casted plastic case
for low power and low frequencies is mainly a factor of production
costs, so if power dissipation
permits there is no longer a reason to prefer a metal case over a
plastic one. Same holds for
old eight-legged opamp ICs which came in a round metal case. For a few
high frequency applications,
though, the metal case makes a Faraday cage which is connected to ground
then. And still, if a lot of
power has to be carried away, the thermal resistance is lower for metal
obivously. For the work horses
2N2222 and 2N3904, this is no real argument though, the 2N3055 with its
15A maximum Ic there are
pretty many Watts to be distributed.
--
Holger