On 10/16/2010 02:06 PM, MikeS wrote:
[[ At first, I thought this would be one of my very rare "Include the
whole gosh darned reply" emails instead of trimming out just the
relevant parts, but then, I guess I do need to put a few comments
interspersed throughout... see where appropriate... ]]
From: Andrew Back <andy at flirble.org>
On (21:02 15/10/10), Tony Duell wrote:
Teo Zenios wrote:
There are many old machines that are worth
preserving but are better
off
in a museum then in somebody's cluttered basement left to rot.
There are cases where that's true - but I know how museums can't
possibly
I feel even more strongly about this, having dealt with some particularly
clueless people at musuems and related organisations [1]. To the extent
that no part of my collection is ever going near a museum.
Tony, does a week ever pass where you don't feel the inescapable urge to
flame those who work at museums, regardless of their knowledge, ability and
track record?
Ah... no, only where their track record seems to be known that said
individuals were not capable of dealing with (let alone preserving)
historical data & hardware... even I saw that!
Admittedly, those that aren't capable, he does highlight (on occasion
"to the extreme") but this is *good* information if others were looking
to donate their equipment and wanted to avoid individuals or
organizations that didn't take good care of donations.
You are rude and insulting. Yes, damned rude even.
Wot? OMG! Say it ain't so!?! I thought the US had a lock on rude
induhviduals.... 'course, at times (more times, recently...), I think I
happen to be one of them as well....
I'm tired of the pussyfooting & mollycoddling (I hope these terms
translate OK to folks who don't speak American) around instead of
"saying what is meant" -- If you don't like what I (or ARD by extension)
have to say - here's a thought: *don't listen.* The delete key was
invented a long time ago for people who don't want to listen... it's
your right not to... use it. ;-)
In the US we (still.... barely...) have freedom of speech. Some places
don't have that. I get that, and I'm OK with that. AFAIK, everybody, no
matter where they live, have at least the freedom to *not listen.*
How dare you make such sweeping generalisations?
[[ snippage of ad nauseum... whatever... ]]
He didn't generalise. He did, however, state that after enough bad
interactions with clueless individuals that worked for/with museums (and
as most in the US are non-profit, they usually take what free /
volunteer help they can get, even if said help is clueless and nearly
useless) that no museum would have access to his items. In the US at
least, that would be his right. As far as I can tell (and IANAS) what
chunks of the Magna Carta that haven't been repealed/rewritten yet also
say he can do what he wants with his stuff, at least until the Queen
changes her mind... ;-)
But, no, it's much easier to take the moral high
ground and boast about how
clever you are and how much of an idiot most everyone else is.
And I've been called an idiot by ARD on at least one occasion (probably
much more than that ;-)... why? Because in his eyes, I am. There are a
lot of machines I own that I can't do chip-level repair on... On said
machines, I'm a board-swapper. I do own machines that he would be
reduced to the same level - he chooses not to own those machines. I do.
Guess what. As far as electronics repair... and you can quote me on
this: "I am an idiot." If I won the lottery tomorrow and could retire &
play with hobbies 24x7, I probably wouldn't be able to learn enough
about electronics troubleshooting & repair to hold a candle to ARD. (Not
to mention chemistry, metalwork or quantum physics...) I'm OK with that.
I do better than most, worse than some others. Sterling to doughnuts
(Hell, I'd take farthings to doughnuts... yes, I have some, yes, you'd
get the better deal!) tho, I probably know a lot more about driving
lorry (despite our steering wheels being on the wrong side... ;-) heavy
equipment[1], routing protocols, homebrewing and candlemaking... so on
those subjects, he's the idiot. ;-) Suffice to say, I doubt he's
offended. If he is, he can reply & say so. ;-)
And here is where Mike's reply begins....
Whoa!
Wot? OMG! Say it ain't so!?! We agree on something? ;-)
Talk about "rude and insulting," and making
"sweeping generalizations"...
He said he's dealt with "some particularly clueless people at museums;"
how
did you get "everyone who works at a museum is an idiot" out of that?
And if he and Curt decide that based on their bad experiences they won't
lend their systems again to a museum, I think that's their choice to make.
Finally, to suggest that he hasn't in fact "contributed to the preservation
of computer history" is preposterous and highly insulting; I don't see many
reverse-engineered HP schematics or extremely helpful posts "working with
people" on here with your name on them...
And, for those who say that ARD "keeps all the info instead of sharing"
--> he shares with the list everything he can, as often as he can, and
as well as he can with the equipment he owns.
Yes, he doesn't own a current scanner (partly because he can't fix it at
the discrete component level, which I may not agree with but is his
right) and may not have high-speed Internet access (again - still his
right - I have relatives that just recently got *electricity*), just
because his form of help "works around" these limitations, doesn't mean
it's not help. He's extremely helpful, even if it's calling someone an
idiot. Myself, I've been "helped" in the past by ARD in such manner, and
even helped a couple others in a similar manner. ;-)
Not many of his contributions are relevant to my
interests but I for one
certainly appreciate the time he spends helping the folks on here, in
the HP community and elsewhere
Right. I'd never even heard of a "crowbar" that wasn't used for
construction demolition before "meeting" ARD. (I've known him for almost
15 years[2], but never met him face-to-face, hence the quotes)
(even if his rants are a little repetitive at times)
> ;-)
And yes, in those "almost 15 years" I must admit... there has been some
repetition. ;-)
Sheesh!
Amen, bruddah!
I must say, that:
1) if you need help, ARD will always take time to help. It may not be
the help you "expect," but in the end you should *learn* from it. If you
don't, it's not ARD's fault. ;-)
2) This email was typed more & more increasingly under the influence of
a magical brew called "beer." Things at the top may seem slightly more
logical than things near the bottom, depending on your level of
sobriety. ;-)
Laterz,
"Merch"
=-=-=
[1] Yes, the backhoe I owned was built in England (JCB) & the owner's
manual _was_ in the Queen's English -- first time I'd seen
"Anti-clockwise" (versus - 'counter-') and "Dazzled" (when
your
high-beams / bright headlights are on) in print... ;-)
[2] Raise your hands -- who on this list are still part of the "Top 20?"
(/me...) ARD is right there... Sellam as well, but he's been quite
silent on the list lately[3]... It would be interesting to see Bill's
original records to see who were the first to sign up... Is that info
even available anymore?
[3] As was I in the recent past... much to everyone's pleasure. I ain't
dead yet, tho! ;-)