2009/6/12 Kirn Gill <segin2005 at gmail.com>:
"free, powerful and useful" does not
describe any viable consumer OS
at the moment.
At point, the only consumer OSes really worth considering (more than
7.5% market share) are Windows and Mac OS X.
If you are trying to apply "free, powerful and useful" to Windows, you
need your head examined.
Well, as the man said, two out of three ain't bad.
It's powerful and it's useful. And in practice, for most people, it
*is* free, because it comes with the computer.
Mac OS X... is an abomination. A design (look and
feel) that sucks
using a interface toolkit (Cocoa) that sucks written in a language
(Objective-C) that sucks.
I am not a programmer, so I have no experience of OS X's development
tools. I've been using it since the first version, though, and I think
it's the least-sucky OS in the world today. In my opinion, it looks
beautiful - the most elegant, stylish and attractive GUI there has
ever been, thus far, and in use, it's the most polished and friendly
OS there has ever been. Its only serious rival in simplicity and ease
of use was its own predecessor, classic MacOS.
These are pretty widely-held opinions, too, as far as I can tell, from
Walt Mossberg on down.
As for the dev tools - well, NeXT's Interface Builder was world-class
(it was, of course, the platform upon which the WorldWideWeb was built
- and it still is pretty damned good. It's not the technical
sophistication of OpenStep that sold it to Apple - BeOS was smaller,
faster, sleeker, vastly more efficient and a lot cheaper. It was the
dev tools, because without developers, it doesn't matter *how* cool
your OS is. To win users, you need apps - good ones and lots of them.
And the Mac's got that. It has some world-leading apps, quite aside
from Apple's own offerings, from SubEthaEdit to
Delicious Library.
So, I'd say, fine, you're entitled to your opinions. Some people don't
like the Mac and OS X. Most of them don't like it because they've
never tried it and they're scared of the new and unfamiliar. This is a
very common syndrome and it applies from clothes to vehicles. I'm a
goth, myself, or at least used to be in my younger days, and only 2yr
ago, a goth girl was beaten to death by a gang here in England just
for looking and dressing differently.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sophie_Lancaster
Myself -- being a looming 6'2" male with a less than sunny disposition
-- nobody ever gave me any trouble, but then, in another realm, I do.
I ride a recumbent bicycle. And just for riding a weird-looking
bicycle, I've been stoned, kicked, threatened and on one occassion
lashed at with a knife as I rode past.
People really don't like the weird. They don't like those who do not conform.
So, lots of PC users pour venom and spite on the Mac and Mac users,
because they're different, and they go on about how much better it is.
But those who actually /try/ it tend to like it, and Apple is winning
millions of converts over to OS X, especially now that it's on Intel
and you can run Windows in a VM and keep your old Windows apps if you
need them.
So, be careful with confidently pronouncing opinions as universal
truths. It's important to know the distinction between your personal
preferences and facts. And beware of proclaiming preferences that may
make you seem to be a bigot, because nobody likes bigotry.
And sadly, it seems no matter what you do, it can'
t get any better,
because all OSes suck, some just suck less than others.
Well, that's true. But some do suck less than others. And when you are
comparing such large and complicated things as 21st-century OSs, well,
you can find areas, even just among the big 3 - Linux, Mac OS X and
Windows - where each sucks in one area but excels in another.
There are things that Windows is good at that OS X is bad at; there
are things that Linux does well that the others do badly; there are
things that all more or less equally on, good or bad. None of them is
clearly and universally better than the others.
--
Liam Proven ? Profile:
http://www.linkedin.com/in/liamproven
Email: lproven at cix.co.uk ? GMail/GoogleTalk/Orkut: lproven at
gmail.com
Tel: +44 20-8685-0498 ? Cell: +44 7939-087884 ? Fax: + 44 870-9151419
AOL/AIM/iChat/Yahoo/Skype: liamproven ? LiveJournal/Twitter: lproven
MSN: lproven at
hotmail.com ? ICQ: 73187508